Dog vs Big daddy.

xvillanx

xvillanx

Newbie
Joined
Aug 25, 2007
Messages
157
Reaction score
0
We all know this would come up and there can only be 1 winner.

By xvillanx
yes i did make it myself before people start claiming copyrite
 
Ennui said:
Yeah but so is Dog, and Dog can effortlessly throw a minivan with two people in it across a 50 foot chasm...
Click to expand...

Exactly and what will a Big Daddy do... Screwdriver him?
 
Mmm, what can a Big Daddy take? What's it strength like? Is it restricted to machine guns? I haven't played Bioshock, dudes.
 
Dog of course. Big daddy can be quick when he charges but that is in a line, no turning. Dog would be all over him. And Dog has a longer reach that the Big Daddy. D:
Imagine Dog putting his hand on the Bid Daddies head to hold him back as he swings, missing each time.

When the player fought Big Daddies all they had to do was side step to avoid his charge. (The Big daddy did well in Bioshock but that was a different world where he was the biggest character.) Dog is pretty fast and strong as well. Remember what he did to that combine vehicle in HL2?
 
Asus said:
Dog of course. Big daddy can be quick when he charges but that is in a line, no turning. Dog would be all over him. And Dog has a longer reach that the Big Daddy. D:
Imagine Dog putting his hand on the Bid Daddies head to hold him back as he swings, missing each time.

When the player fought Big Daddies all they had to do was side step to avoid his charge. (The Big daddy did well in Bioshock but that was a different world where he was the biggest character.) Dog is pretty fast and strong as well. Remember what he did to that combine vehicle in HL2?
Click to expand...

Not to mention the unfortunate Overwatch soldiers that ended up below it.
 
Narvi said:
Mmm, what can a Big Daddy take? What's it strength like? Is it restricted to machine guns? I haven't played Bioshock, dudes.
Click to expand...
Think basically like a slow-moving, clumsy Hunter. Extremely strong melee attacks, pretty good ranged; heavily armored against weapons fire, not so much against explosives and physics.

I'd expect Dog to take one down even more easily than he does the dropship in HL2 or
the Strider
in Ep2. More agility, longer reach, better armor.
 
Dog is more versatile; Big Daddy would have the upper-hand close range but still, Dog would probably win out.
 
Reasons for DOG

Dog is more Aerodynamic as he is made up from composite/lightweight materials, and the hydraulics system that is used in dog is so powerful that he can pick up a vehicle and hurl it, and is capable of jumping to great heights. So this mean that death can come from 3 dimensions as opposed to the conventional 2 dimensions. Effectively a machine that is capable of observing changes in the battlefield, he will then be able to take a suitable course of action.
 
Dog is strong and all but the big daddie would win , for starters you never fight dog so you dont know how much he could take because you never see him take a direct hit , the big daddy also has extremly strong body power and can take a punch. You have to remember that dog is not bulky at all , and could not take a hit from the big daddies drill.
Thank you and good night , much luck:thumbs:
 
The Big Daddy with the Rivet gun would have a good advantage. And if the battle was underwater, the Big Daddy is in its natural environment.

Gotta remember there's two types of Daddy's: The melee one, and the ranged one. Also there are elite versions of both, and i think only the elites would be a match.
 
The daddy would never, ever be able to get Dog with his drill.
 
Remember that Dog is a robot as well. He would have way better reflexes, and resistance to pain (obviously).
 
Realistically? They're both awful. Dog is like, made out of scrap, his arm would probably fall off half way through. And Big Daddies are just hot and sweaty guys in diving suits... it'd just fall over exhausted after one swing.

HAHA I BURST ALL YOUR BUBBLES.
 
Hmm, dog would just throw minivans and jump whenever Bubbles rushes.
 
Okay, first of all, as i mentioned earlier there are two Big Daddys:

Rosie
Rosie carries a rivet gun, a reference to Rosie the Riveter. In addition to their powerful ranged attack, they occasionally throw proximity mines; as with all projectiles, these can be caught and thrown back with Telekinesis (once they deploy, they cannot be picked up and will remain until detonated).

Bouncer
The Bouncer is the iconic Big Daddy, with his many tiny portholed eyes. They only have melee attacks, but can charge the player at high speed. They're shorter, but more powerful and aggresive than Rosies.

Dog would kick a Bouncers ass without doubt, but a Rosie (An angry female as well - we all know those are dangerous) would be a very fair match.

And to clarify what a Big Daddy is:
Big Daddies are human beings who have had their skin and organs grafted into an enormous diving suit. The candidates also go through voice box modulation and pheromone application. This pheromone is what attracts the Little Sisters to the Big Daddies. They are then injected with a plasmid that effectively turns them into mindless drones with only one purpose: to protect the Little Sisters.
Click to expand...

They are by no means human any longer. Only a bunch of super powered genetically modified organs, melted together with a steel suit. (You find out in Bioshock, that there is no way to seperate the human from the suit - there's probably leftovers of many individuals inside those suits, as they need replacement once in a while) Dog would have to attack the Big Daddy, or hurt a Little Sister to even make a Daddy bother fighting him. If you haven't noticed, Big Daddys have no thought at all - they are totally unaware of their surroundings, as long as they do not harm themselves or their Little Sister.

However, Dog is more powerfull, in that it can probably throw a Big Daddy. A daddy is very tough though, so it can most likely take a few throws before collapsing. A Rosie would have an advantage if it can get distance from Dog, as its rivet gun will tear Dogs fragile body apart.

(Information from http://bioshock.wikia.com/wiki/Big_Daddy)
 
Hmm.

The Bouncer could probably injure Dog but Dog would manage to defeat it.

The Rosie would also probably get defeated by Dog easily. Dog defeats Combine Soldiers easily after all.

Yeah, Dog would beat both kinds of Big Daddies somewhat easily.

In coolness though I say it's a tie.
 
Oooof that would be a tough match, but lets look at it rationally.

Big Daddies:
For starters, Big Daddies are built in the early sixties, and, while highly resistant to gunfire and, to a lesser extent, explosives, it would be far less effective in a future setting..
Big Daddies are classified into two different versions: Bouncers and Rosies. Rosies are armed with high velocity rivet guns, which hurt like a mother, and are also equipped with mild explosive proximity mines. Bouncers however have no ranged attacks to speak of, other than a ground smash which dazes the opponent effectively.

Dog:
If we look at Dog's anatomy, he has some very clear weaknesses: http://developer.valvesoftware.com/w/images/4/49/D0g.jpg
We see the wires that connect Dog's hands to his shoulders. I know if I were the big daddy I would be going for one of those wires. Not to say those wires are easily severed, but a Bouncer's drill? who knows.
Dog is also most likely heavily reinforced with far more advanced materials, and equipped with a very intelligent and quick AI. Another advantage we can see here is that, most likely, being a robot, Dog is impervious to pain, which is not a case for a Big Daddy.

Dog vs Bouncer:
I would most likely give this fight to the Bouncer. At first I thought Dog, but to beat the Bouncer, Dog has to place himself perilously close to the bouncer's drill, which would likely snap his wires, severing his joints, or go through his face. I doubt the bouncer's ground smash would daze dog, as his mind is a computer.

Dog vs Rosie:
I would hand this fight over to Dog. Rosies are far weaker than a bouncer in close range, and when Dog gets close to the Rosie, he would go to work and just destroy it. The Rivet Gun cannot possibly match power with the guns of the Half Life universe. A futuristic gun could outmatch any weapon in the sixties. The explosives would easily be avoided, or even thrown back at the Rosie by Dog, who clearly has zero-point energy manipulation capabilities.
 
What can the rivet gun do, exactly? Is it just a reappropriated repair tool?
 
Guys, GUYS! You are seriously underestimating Dog here...

Killing combine soldiers? That doesn't even count...
Throwing minivans across chasms? Not impressive.
Tearing apart APCs and striders? Nice to watch...

And a lot of other things, that look painful are really not a problem at all to Dog.

Should i remind you that in the end of "anticitizen one" (?), Dog lifts up a combine wall segment?
Dog is NOT so easily defeated, as you think. Well maybe the strider VS. Dog scene, but he still tears it apart.

My votes definately go to Dog...Big daddies are wussies.
 
Narvi said:
What can the rivet gun do, exactly? Is it just a reappropriated repair tool?
Click to expand...

I would compare the Rivet Gun to a superpowered shotgun with pinpoint accuracy.

Kinda like anabelle, only more powerful. Definately armorpiercing, extremely painful.

Nothing about the Big Daddy is reappropriated. The Big Daddy is tooled for the purpose of protecting the Little Sister.


Oh, and I HIGHLY suggest you play Bioshock. It really is a triumph.
 
dog alyx = little sister
Click to expand...

19979741hy7.jpg
HalfLife2_Dog.jpg



EXACTLY THE SAME!!!1!


:p not exactly.
 
Its on opinoin , but im sure every1 can agree , it would be a fight to remember and a fight to tell our childrens children :)

P.S comment on photo :)
 
RNEvermore said:
I would compare the Rivet Gun to a superpowered shotgun with pinpoint accuracy.

Kinda like anabelle, only more powerful. Definately armorpiercing, extremely painful.

Nothing about the Big Daddy is reappropriated. The Big Daddy is tooled for the purpose of protecting the Little Sister.


Oh, and I HIGHLY suggest you play Bioshock. It really is a triumph.
Click to expand...

Refire rate? Because Dog shrugs off assault rifle rounds and rockets.

And I can't play Bioshock. My rig can barely handle Episode 1.
 
Hey, dog dies after 1 combine ball, 1 hit from the elite bouncers drill would shatter it.
 
Heh, after what I saw last night, my assumptions are confirmed.
 
We have a basic idea. He's taken rockets in-game.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Krynn72
You guys, what the **** is up.
Replies
11
Views
2K
Tollbooth Willie
Tollbooth Willie
TechnoHippyChic
If you post it, they will come...
2
Replies
63
Views
6K
TechnoHippyChic
TechnoHippyChic
B
Barking Dog Studios' work for Valve
Replies
0
Views
12K
Barnz
B
MFL
Fascinating look at the ongoing psychological evolution of flat hieirarchies.
Replies
2
Views
2K
Tollbooth Willie
Tollbooth Willie
bbson john
Hi everyone. I am new to this forum!
Replies
11
Views
6K
Tollbooth Willie
Tollbooth Willie
Back
Top