Half Life From The Eyes Of a G-Man

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pegcrab
  • Start date Start date
P

Pegcrab

Guest
I think that the combine isn't the only interdimentional super-power, I think there are more factions fighting for control.

There is a lot of evidence in Half-Life and Half-Life 2 that Xen is used as a kid of pit stop for teleporters, they go through Xen before reaching thier final destination. I think that once the Combine controlled it, they pretty much could control their enemies ability to teleport. This caused all the other factions to panic and band together to find a solution, after all, it's hard to wage inter-dimentional war without the ability to teleport between the dimentions.

One of these super powers is neutral - it gains power and influence by taking contracts from the other factions and playing them against each other. They are payed with eiter money, cabinet seats in the faction's goverments, or entire planets, depending on the job. The G-Man represents this faction. He completes jobs he is given, but rarely gets his hands dirty. He usually looks for subjects that will do his job for him by placing them in situations where they have really no choice at all, or would do it by themselves, willingly, like how Gordon kills Nihilanth and destroys the Citadel.

After the Combine take control of Xen, the other factions unite and try to attack Xen. However, the combination of the Combine forces as well as the Xen geography causes them to fail, again and again. In desperation they contact the Mercenary Faction and ask for help.

The G-Man is tasked with finding a way to overthrow the Combine control of Xen. He knows that there is no hope of doing so using 'champions' from the different faction, so he travels to a tiny planet that has been overlooked by them all - Earth. He travels to every major nation on the planet, looking for someone who could overthrow the Combine on Xen. We know from OF that the G-Man followed Colonel Shepard's unit closely, so I can assume he decided that they would be the right men for the job. And so the G-Man arranges form the resonance cascade to happen. Shepard's plane is shot down however, and most of his unit is killed. The G-man sees that Shepard in indeed very capable, and doesn't let him evacuate with the rest of the soldiers. What the G-Man didn't expect was for Gordon Freeman to show more promise then Shepards unit. I think it was only by chance that Freeman was where he was when the cascade happened, and I think that's what suprised the G-Man the most. Freeman showed amazing potential and ended up killing Nihilanth instead of Shepard. Shepard and Freeman are both kept in stasis.

Meanwhile, the Combine control of Xen falls apart, as Nihilanth was their representetive there, without him they had very little control over the native Xenians. The faction that the G-Man represents decideds to forget the contract they made this the faction rebelling against the combine, and take Xen for themselves ("the borderworld is now under control by the goverment I represent"). This action causes them to lose influence inside all the other factions. They now use Xen as an interdimentional toll booth - you can still get where ever you want, but you have to pay a tax. They still act as a mercenary service, but less then before. They are willing to sell mercenaries to other factions, to do with them as they will, meaning that the mercenaries don't have to do jobs anymore, they will just be released to whichever faction is willing to pay the most for them.

The Combine are obviously pissed after loosing control of Xen, and take over Earth to take revenge on th humans, and hopefully find Freeman and make him pay.

Now, for my little G-Man theory. The G-Man is not happy with the desicion to take over Xen. He reports that Shepard was killed, and hides him and a few more of his mercenaries, waiting for a chance to take over the faction he works for and return the old status qou.

The resistance make contact with the G-Man and cut a deal with him - he can take any soldier of theirs he wants in exchange for Freeman. The G-Man takes this offer, even though he was offered more money and power by all the other factions, because he firmly belives that humans are unpredictable, and are the best soldiers, and any human soldier he gets will help him in his revolution. Secretly, he has plans for Gordon. He also thinks that one of his strongest assests is Shepard, his employers think he's dead, and he's shown he's capable enough.

At the end of Half Life 2, the citadel explodes. For the G-Man, this is a dream come true. He tells his employers Gordon is dead, and puts him in stasis.

I think in Half Life 3 we will see Gordon fighting along Shepard and any suriving characters from Half-Life 2 fighting the G-Man's revolution, and helping him kill his employers. I think Gordon may take on the G-Man at the end, fearing that he will be put into stasis again.

I'm sorry I made you read all that. I hope this is makes sense.
 
Looooooooong post.....sorry dude I guess I have attention deficit disorder or maybe I'm just lazy.....can you summarise it?!
 
It'll be hard. Baby steps man, one paragraph at a time. Come on, you can do it.

I'm sorry it's so long, it's specualtion about the entire series, so it's hard to summarise.
 
I can actually see HL3 turning into an AntiGman game, with him being the enemy.

In the end I dont think anybody truly knows what the Gman's motives are. He has shown obvious compassion for mankind in the general idea of bringing Gordon back to stop the Combine, but I think his plans and reasons go much deeper than that. Who his benifactors are, and what goal the serve is completely unknown.

I also dont think you could arrange the Combine, Xen, and Gman into different catagories. There's clearly a link with it all somewhere, and I wouldnt be surprising if the Gman's benifactors were in some way associated, for either good or bad, with the Combine.

Breen's message to Freeman at the end is the most interesting;
"Did you not know you were open to the highest bidder?"
 
Like I said, once the G-Man's benefactors took control of Xen, they didn't need their mercenaries as much any more, and were willing to sell them off to the highest bidder. The G-Man sold Freeman to the resistance for human soldiers he would use for his revolution.
 
I think Gordon may take on the G-Man at the end, fearing that he will be put into stasis again.

The G-man cannot be defeated if he can put you in stasis whenever he feels like it. This fact alone suggests the g-man's power. We should keep in mind that the gman is pulling all the strings. I imagine the g-man could put dr.breen in statsis and the all of the combine as well, but he refrains from using his powers for a reason....and I don't know what it is, most likely his employers
 
Those are some very good points. This is why I love this forum....
 
pomegranate said:
Looooooooong post.....sorry dude I guess I have attention deficit disorder or maybe I'm just lazy.....can you summarise it?!
Damn... lazy. Reading is good for you...

My only problem with the theory (and it’s a personal problem ;)) is that the combine appear to be a cold and rational force. I don’t see them as being subject emotions like revenge or punishment. I think every action they execute is the one that improves their condition the most. They would never sidetrack to do something that wouldn’t be the most efficient use of their power. They hunt freeman during the game because they know that he poses a huge risk… so it’s certainly in their best interest throw a lot at him. They are more like a force of nature then a humanlike intelligence. That’s how I perceived them anyway. Something has to be totally inhuman to make stalkers.

Take out raising the bar and take a good long hard look at page 78 picture 2.

Damn.

I think of the combine as being possibly an “artificial intelligence” that, seeing biological life as another type of machine, decides that we are “broken” because we act illogically. Or at least it perceives us to be acting illogically. So it fixes us. Now we serve a purpose and work “right.” Does it give a rat’s ass about pain and suffering caused… no it can’t even imagine what pain really is plus it deems it irrelevant.

The reason such a “perfect” force can’t stop freeman is because he is somehow fundamentally unpredictable to them… Which is why the g-man knows he is valuable. (and consequently why he really is a “Free man”) I think something happened during the resonance cascade to make him that way. The vortigaunts seem obsessed with him the being the “Freeman.” Perhaps they did something to him to shrug off the yoke of combine oppression. But it’s just pure speculation…

Hmm... Didn’t mean to pollute your thread with my theory… I just started talking about the combine and well…. It kept going.
Cheers anyhow,

Edit:I guess should clarify before someone thinks I’m smoking crack… My theory assumes the combine advisor is not the true face of the combine… just another subjugated race.
 
The theory boils down to this : the G-Man is from an alien race [and has taken a human host body, I might add] that has positioned itself in a stance of power that puts them "above it all," because they are smarter than everyone else in the universe.

But an opponent's weapons can be turned on him. Time-travel, etc, whatever technology they use, we can incorporate.
 
beam said:
The G-man cannot be defeated if he can put you in stasis whenever he feels like it. This fact alone suggests the g-man's power. We should keep in mind that the gman is pulling all the strings. I imagine the g-man could put dr.breen in statsis and the all of the combine as well, but he refrains from using his powers for a reason....and I don't know what it is, most likely his employers

Of course the G-Man can be defeated. He would have no use for Gordon if he had no weakness. Plus, the fact that he is an employee of something greater then him suggests that there probably are more powerful beings then him.

That's actually a very good theory, Is This Tea, but it still doesn't contradict mine, entirely. I said up there that one of the reasons that the combine took over earth was to find Freeman. Another one could be that Breen knew that the resistance was close to finding a way to teleport without having to stop in Xen, something that the Combine would be extremly interested in, because it would gain an upper hand over it's enemies again with that technology.
 
G-man's people and the Combine are definatly opposing interdementional empires.
I hope HL3 has multiple endings, like Deus Ex.
 
Pegcrab said:
What the G-Man didn't expect was for Gordon Freeman to show more promise then Shepards unit. I think it was only by chance that Freeman was where he was when the cascade happened, and I think that's what suprised the G-Man the most.

"The right man in the wrong place can make all the difference in the world."

As for who, or what the Combine are, I think its fairly obvious that their role on Earth is not exactly clear.

Breen hold a lot more power that what people think. Its quite possible the Combine rely on him for some reason. Perhaps the Combine had no way of reaching Earth at all without Breen's help.

Breen wants to improve mankind. This is not the Combine's wishes, this is not the Combine's plans, this is Breen's. His experiments in transhumanation pressure him to want to improve man. His speaches throughout the game prove this, and Stalkers help as well. The Combine obviously offered Breen the chance to live out his dream of playing God, but what did they want in return?

Who knows. Its possible it was the planet's resorces they wanted. In Breen's final communication's with the big nasty Combine bug near the end he speaks of "delivering Earth". Not man, not the creatures that enhabit it, but Earth itself. If the Combine really had a pure interest in man for revenge they could have easily betrayed Breen and killed everyone off.

Perhaps the Combine's desire of Earth is linked to Xen. Earth would be part of the last demension to ever come in contact with Xen, so perhaps the Combine believe that in controlling Earth they will get access to Xen.

Evidence for this can be found in the desire to capture Eli Vance. Eli clearly isnt up for transhumanation, but he sure knows a hell of a lot about teleportation, PARTICUALLY to Xen. The Combine also are not capable of teleporting back and forth, and were essentially 'stuck' on Earth without the Xen teleportation device.

Oops, went off topic there with my own theory. Sorry :/.
 
The Combine needed Breen on earth so that he could keep order till the actual Combine move in, once Earth is formed more like the Combine homeworld and they can move in.

And EatChildren - it's ok that you went off topic, your theory still fits with mine, you helped my theory more then contradict it.

Breen wants to help humanity, but he's not trying to make the Combine work for him, he thinks that by following orders he's helping mankind.

I think we can discount the Combine wanting Earth for revenge, I'm tending to lean now more towards them wanting Earth to find Freeman and find out how mankind could possibly take Xen from them, trying to find out what makes them so powerful. I think they were getting frustrated that they were failing, they found humans to be weak, and they can't comprehend that their biggest advantage is that they are unpredictable. They don't see that because they are too cold and calculating.
 
Breen wants to help humanity, but he's not trying to make the Combine work for him, he thinks that by following orders he's helping mankind.

I am not sure about this, sure he saved earth from doom but he was after his won skin as well, not mentioning combine technolgy.

Too me he is out for himself, its self evident, especially when he states:

"Having both of you in my keeping ensures i can dictate the terms of any bargain...i care to make with the combine *laughter*"

I think he is out for himself, but then again what he wants for mankind isnt whats best anyway heh.
 
I thought about it, I even started one, but I decided that pouring so much effort into it would be a waste of time. It's kind of like playing in a cover band full time. You may write something nice, but in the end it's not entirly yours, the bulk of it is taken from other people. That's what I don't like.
 
Pegcrab said:
I thought about it, I even started one, but I decided that pouring so much effort into it would be a waste of time. It's kind of like playing in a cover band full time. You may write something nice, but in the end it's not entirly yours, the bulk of it is taken from other people. That's what I don't like.
For sure
"Bad artists copy. Good artists steal." -Pablo Picasso
 
OR...

Laidlaw hasn't quite decided who G-Man is, and so is leaving as many ends open as possible.

In an interview somewhere, Laidlaw stated that when the original Half-Life was created, they'd not planned any story for Half-Life 2 (which is why my theory of Xen being completely seperate from the Combine is probably right).
What makes you think he's planned anything for HL3 yet? He's left as many doors open in the plot as possible - it gives him loads of options for the next game.

-Angry Lawyer
 
ppl are always complaining how Race X (op force) don't fit inot the picture, they could be another faction (Combine, G-Man's faction, etc) i just thought that that strand of info might show a bit more insight, to how much Laidlaw might of acuttaly planned Op Force with GearBox, only an idea tho
 
I don't think Laidlaw actually had much to do with OpFor's plot.

Lawyer - I don't think he planned the plot because they didn't even know for sure that there would be a Half-Life 2, it was the studio's first effort, and if they didn't sell enough copies they wouln't be able to work on a sequel. Now it's obvious that there will be a sequel, both games have sold astronomical amounts of copies, and HL2 is suck a great setup for a sequel. I think that after the original half life did so well Laidlaw laid out the rest of the plot.
 
Ok... lets see here.

The Combine are a cold, clinical race (or at least give that impression). So the revenge thing is unlikely (yes, it's been said...). What i believe the Combine want earth for is the one thing it has that many others don't.

Life.

The goal of the combine, in my eyes, is to take as many species as possible, and "combine" (hehe, PUN!) them with other species to make the perfect soldiers. If they don't have the ability, then they take whatever species they have first (i.e. Synths) and use them to supress the dominant species until they have worked a way to stick pins and flesh onto places they shouldn't go.
The reason the Overwatch is human (or at least, humanoid) is because they were human when they joined the Metro Cops (That dude in the food line... "I might join the Overwatch just to get a decent meal"), and then got completely drugged and turned into the clinical sort of stuff the combine original race likes.
*wanders back on topic*
I, personally, would prefer not to fight the G-man, and simply find out who he is, what his motives are.
I also like your use of the word "unpredictability". That rocks. :)
 
To make it clear, the whole half life serie story is already all written down since the beggining, it's 1000pages long i think, also, laidlaw wrote the story for Op4 and BS.
 
evilsloth said:
ppl are always complaining how Race X (op force) don't fit inot the picture...

They fit into my theory pretty well.
 
laidlaw wrote the story for Op4 and BS.

No he never.

Originally Posted by Marc Laidlaw
Hi, Solver, I'm assuming whatever I tell you is going to get posted somewhere, so I'll be very careful in answering.

I will not talk about the meaning of the game or clear up stuff that has yet to be clarified or revealed; it only makes sense to do this in the context of the games themselves. Stuff that hasn't been revealed is that way because we're not ready to reveal it. Everything that's there is there for a reason; ditto for everything that isn't there. I can only say, "Stay tuned."

Race-X was Gearbox's creation, and likely would only be continued if Gearbox were to do more episodes in the HL universe. There were gameplay modes they wanted to explore, and their designers wanted to make some new monsters; Race-X was a great way for them to do this. The universe is expansive enough to allow this without conflicting with the core story. Remember, these are games first and foremost, and the story really is there to open up and extend (rather than shut down) possibilities for fun gameplay. We did coordinate overarching story elements with Gearbox, but left a lot of the details for them to explore and invent according to what worked for their design process. As for whether Shepherd was put on ice before or after the Nihilanth's demise, it's really hard to say, since Gordon's time in Xen and in the Nihilanth's chamber may not be mapped directly against the timeline of events at Black Mesa.

The gman mumbles sound fairly close to what I remember him saying...strangely enough, I can't find the script for that exchange.

Thanks for taking such an interest in the story. Before HL1 came out, it was tough to convince outsiders that FPS players would care at all about having any kind of story in their game. Obviously, given the wide range of reactions, they care quite a bit. The debate over HL2's content is much more varied.

Yours,
Marc Laidlaw
 
Still doesn't change much. We might not see anymore of Race X, but obviously that wont contradict the continuing plot of the series in any way.
 
Back
Top