If put in a cage, who would come out alive?

[ph34r t3h cute]

Fight fight fight fight!

Yea Im bored.. Bleh, lets talk about lord of the rings en stuff!

 

[h00dlum]

Seriosly get a life willya? Smeagol and Golum have the same physical body so i guess both of them would coe out..

 

[Dedalus]

Gollum would win, because obviously Smeagul would win, so that would mean Gollum won. i'm a genius what can i say. FART!!!

 

[DarkelP]

Smeagol would win, becasue he's he original inhabitant of the body, therfore he would win.

 

[Fender357]

Originally posted by Dedalus
Gollum would win, because obviously Smeagul would win, so that would mean Gollum won. i'm a genius what can i say. FART!!!

He's got ya there.

But Gollum............he was the mean one.

 

[ph34r t3h cute]

Originally posted by h00dlum
Seriosly get a life willya? Smeagol and Golum have the same physical body so i guess both of them would coe out..

Oh yea thats right, ruin my fun.

And I have a life, it may be different too yours, but im happy with it :dozey:

Anyways, Smeagol would win cus he would whine like a LITTLE GIRL till gollum goes away :bounce:

 

[D33]

Smeagul once mentally defeated his alter ego by getting mad and unleashing his true mental power and telling his alter ego to go away.

If he did the same thing physically he'd win again.

 

[Brian Damage]

Going for ol' Smeagol because I feel sorry for the little dude. If he put his half of their mind to it, I'm sure he could win.

What a metaphysical thread.

 

[pHATE1982]

I've read the third book so I know who would win. But I wouldn't want to spoil the film for those who havn't read it.

:cheers:

 

[theGreenBunny]

phate, it's a physical fighting situation, not the mental 'battle' as read in the books

Anyway, Gollum is ee-vul, and will therefore fight dirty and win.
The world is so simple.

 

[BlazeKun]

Good always wins vs. Evil for the simple fact that good is good to others, while evil is evil to others. So the combined power of Good far exceeds the singled power of evil. Simple = )

 

[pHATE1982]

As they are the same person/thing surley it would all come down to a mental battle in the end?

 

[king John I]

smeagle would win, because thats what i call my sister