Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring

Sui

Tank
Joined
Jan 15, 2004
Messages
5,998
Reaction score
3
Honour. Valour. Pride. Sacrifice. Love. Hope.

These are the things that Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring make me feel. I am inspired by its grace, its beauty, its fragility. It is a downhearted, bleak tale of desperation- to save a doomed populace from inevitable destruction. Shadow covers Middle-earth, and every race living in it feels the depressing, crushing inescapable end that is coming. No army can withstand the shadow. No army can relieve Middle earth of this burden.

But yet, within the chaos and the depression there is a small fraction of hope. Where both men and elves retreat, frightened and repelled by something they cannot see, there is always courage found in even the most unlikely of places- and if it weren’t for this courage, this ignorant, fools hope- everything would be lost. Which is why hobbits are so important in this story- where everything else fails, they are the only creatures who ludicrously daydream of a way out- they blindly believe that things will be all right in the end. And if there weren’t anybody who believed this, there would be no-body to make it happen.

And so I come to the meaning of the story. For me, Lord of the Rings is about hope. Nothing other than hope. It is what drives us forward when the path is dark, and what inspires us when we don’t know what to do. It persuades us that there is a point in trying, and that there is meaning in this life. Without hope, without the valour that it gives us, we would all surely perish in our own despair.


Now, as you have probably guessed, I just watched Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring on special edition DVD again- In perperation for when I get The return of the king on DVD.



My favourite scene has to be the mines of Moria. During that scene, despite the fact that there is no immediate danger, the atmosphere builds a huge amount of tension, leaving you on the edge of your seat. You feel a strange unreast in the air- like something is hiding, waiting for you. The climax of the scene really starts to climb when Gandalf is reading the book he prized from a dead dwarf’s hand… The music is silent and there is nothing but the dramatic, yet deeply faltering voice of Gandalf- repeating the final words of this doomed dwarf. And then, just as the tension has reached it’s highest and Gandalf utters the words, “they are coming”… everything goes silent and Pippin dislodges the skeleton of a dwarf.

Clang.
Clang. Clang.
Clang.


The silence is broken by a terribly loud echo that booms through your ears and puts your hairs on end, before quickly darting back into the gloomy silence.

And then from all around, slowly but surely, drums and snarls and clatters and shuffles rise from the dark and cloud your ears with tension- you are terrified of an enemy you haven’t seen yet- you are uncertain, unaware of what is coming… The doors are barred and the fellowship stand waiting… what is coming? What is scaring me so much? What is-

BOOM.

The doors are flung open, and from the darkness erupts a flood of warriors, who immediately clash with our heroes and duel with our senses. It is an amazing way of keeping the tension built- the climax is at its highest and we are loving it. Truly, for me, this was one of my favourite moments in cinema, and one of the most powerful ways of setting an atmosphere with sound, music and visual uncertainty. Wonderful.



And I will leave you with an interesting fact: Did you know that the Lord of the Rings, Fellowship of the Ring Extended DVD has HALF AN HOUR of credits? At first I couldn’t believe it, but then I checked and checked again and sure enough there is over 25 minutes of credits. Good music throughout them as well, as the credits are just coming to an end as I write this ;)
 
Suicide42 said:
And I will leave you with an interesting fact: Did you know that the Lord of the Rings, Fellowship of the Ring Extended DVD has HALF AN HOUR of credits? At first I couldn’t believe it, but then I checked and checked again and sure enough there is over 25 minutes of credits. Good music throughout them as well, as the credits are just coming to an end as I write this ;)

The extended films are marvels to behold.

the credits contain the names of everyone in the LOTR fanclub. The list goes on for ages and ages, but this film needed some serious funding and hard work for all the prop making and set, locations etc. its amazing and extremely well done with the franchise. You'd expect such a film to be a flop but its superb, its so deep and so full of action at the same time. I'd say the extended editions are pretty much perfect, just missing the evil human killing within the overrun shire at the end of LOTR:ROTK in the books.
 
Personally the biggest thing left out of the movies for me was the fact that Gimli goes West with Legolas at the end. Thier building friendship in the books was one of the best parts for me.


All in all tho i found the movies excellent and well made. I have been waiting for someone to make these movies for a long time and it was worth the wait. My gf got sick of going to the theaters watching them 3 or 4 times the first week they came out, she got me the extended collection for my b-day.
 
I agree RogueFox.

The cutting out of Saruman at the end of ROTK was almost unforgivable as well :/

Even so, the extended versions are fantastic, so much better than I believed possible (the casting for Gandalf was inspired)
 
I love all three of the movies.

The music and atmosphere really get to ya.
 
Those credits are really annoying (considering they seriously eat into the bitrate of each movie and no one with a life reads them anyway). I mean couldnt they have just printed a document with all the names on rather than having 30 minutes of scrolling?
 
Amen to all that.
My mom just got me the Gift Set for the Return of the King: EE.
I have all three, and I love 'em.
 
I dont have the 3rd one yet, going to get it after xmas.
 
I have all three extended editions. I have read the book(s) a load of times. My nick is inspired by the line of rulers in Gondor.

Tolkien was a genious, and I love all of his work. To bad he died so many years ago.
 
Warbie said:
I agree RogueFox.

The cutting out of Saruman at the end of ROTK was almost unforgivable as well :/

*cough* ROTK extended edition :D it's 40 minutes longer :O
 
I love both the books and the movies. I haven't seen RotK:EE yet, but I will be getting it for christmas.
 
Warbie said:
I agree RogueFox.

The cutting out of Saruman at the end of ROTK was almost unforgivable as well :/

Even so, the extended versions are fantastic, so much better than I believed possible (the casting for Gandalf was inspired)

His death was moved to the beginning of the extended version of ROTK, at Isengard. :) The scourging of the shire simply would not have worked for a movie, it's too anti-climatic. I actually thought it worked better when he wasn't in ROTK; I think it only works if you're watching them all in a row, as one movie. But it IS cool.
 
I have the extended box set and I can honestly say that it's the best bang for buck box set out there (I paid £45 and I know you can probably find it cheaper), but it's still a fantastic deal.

I also bought ROTK from dvd.co.uk (preorder) for 17.99 and got sick of waiting for it to arrive (took a week) (which is why I bought the set) and stuck the single version on ebay along with my old FOTR set (both sold for £32 so I was happy).

BTW anyone in the uk want ROTK EE cheap:

www.sendit.com - £17.49
www.dvd.co.uk - £17.99
 
KagePrototype said:
His death was moved to the beginning of the extended version of ROTK, at Isengard. :) The scourging of the shire simply would not have worked for a movie, it's too anti-climatic. I actually thought it worked better when he wasn't in ROTK; I think it only works if you're watching them all in a row, as one movie. But it IS cool.

seriously, the movies ruined the books for me... i'm going to have to read them again.

What i mean is, after i saw the movies, i COMPLETELY forgot what happened in the books, and i can't remember how i visualised the story at the time. I can't even remember the scouring of the shire, and that wasn't even in the film! all i can remember is that wormtounge and saruman walk off into the distance, and

Wormtounge stabs saruman in the back... or is it the other way round? i forget.


The stupid thing is i only read the books a few years ago, before the films were released. But then again i am shit at remembering things... i actually CAN'T remember what happens in any of the books that i've read.. .no seriosuly, i've only just discovered this while i'm typing... ARRRGHH what happens in the northern lights? i can't remember! I can't even remember what's happening in The heart of darkness, and i'm reading that now :x
Shit, i just forgot japanese! ....hey wait... i cant speak japanese... ARGH!!! Oh wait, i just remembered how to speak japanese, and i never learnt!!! damn i'm strange.
 
Very nice films but I can't help but wish that the enormous resources and financial support and care could be taken over a brand new and original story.

Personally, while I think they're good stuff with some absolutely astonishingly good work in a huge number of areas, I also think they are very over-rated. To me, the story isn't particularly good with fairly flat characters and a poor ending. And how many times did Return of the King want to end?!?!?!

Still enjoy them but it would have been even better if the story was the work of a more talented and inspiring writer. Just my personal thoughts on it bearing in mind that my favourite writers would be closer to people like Charlie Kaufman and Tom Stoppard.
 
Back
Top