Manhunt vs The Suffering

[Newbie's Journey]

Both looks ultra violent, bloody, dark, creepy, dirty, etc. Which one is better in term of gameplay ?

 

[DarkStar]

They both suck.

 

[Newbie's Journey]

for real ?? both suck ?? plz tell me why, cuz i'm thinking to get one of these games. Manhunt got 8,3 on gamespot.

 

[Neo_Kuja]

Manhunt doesn't have much thrill after you do some "executions" and witness them all.
It's kind of like deciding between a bucket of crap and a bucket of puke.

Which is better ?

 

[burnzie]

i love manhunt, its cool.

i havent played the suffering but i heard it was alright?

 

[Mechagodzilla]

Manhunt looks like crap in a hat. The Suffering looks like lower budget, less intellectual hat-crap.

The correct answer is Metal Gear Solid.
It's not dark and ultra-gory, but it certainly doesn't suck.

 

[DarkStar]

If you're looking to buy a medicore game I'd go with Psi-Ops which I'm enjoying much more than either of those two.

 

[Bio]

They both suck, and its only game a that fits 10-12 year old fanatics.

 

[Direwolf]

Actually I've heard a lot of people praising Manhunt, especially for its very delibirate gameplay. I've certainly never heard that of The Suffering.

 

[Newbie's Journey]

they both rated matured

 

[joule]

Go get The Suffering
It has a simple but compelling story and ripping things in half with giant monster claws is just pure fun
Midway sure is a having a good year
Manhunt has dull levels and it's button-mashing fighting at its best
Rockstar sure tripped and fell face-first on this one

 

[Pressure]

Go get The Suffering
It has a simple but compelling story and ripping things in half with giant monster claws is just pure fun
Midway sure is a having a good year
Manhunt has dull levels and it's button-mashing fighting at its best
Rockstar sure tripped and fell face-first on this one

You aren't supose to go toe-to-toe with an enemy so I wouldn't call it a button masher.

 

[B_MAN]

manhunt is just sick.
at least the suffering has a storyline.. not just senseless killing

 

[Pressure]

Manhunt has a story. I'm guessing you've played it for like 5 minutes?

 

[joule]

Oh yeah, did I mention that Manhunt is very repetitive?
Sneak, lurk, kill, repeat.

 

[jonbob]

They are both pants. Naff. Poo.

 

[lans]

If you're looking to buy a medicore game I'd go with Psi-Ops which I'm enjoying much more than either of those two.

Psi-ops is by no means mediocre (not medicore). It's a very fine example of amazing physics in a game and very good enemy A.I. Sure the graphics aren't that good, but who cares?

 

[Newbie's Journey]

i would like to play psi-ops, but it doesn't have pc version. Well finally i got manhunt and hitman 3. Both are about killing.

 

[burnzie]

hitman 3 is good, so's manhunt, but no one agrres with me.

 

[<RJMC>]

I didnt hav play much manhunt to judge it

but I love the suffering
maybe dont hav best graphics ever but is really cool
I love the suffering
I recomend it