My First Sigs ever made

[SenorDingDong]

Hey, Im finally learning to make sigs, and am wondering what you guys think about these.

These are my first two sigs ive ever really made.

What do you guys think? I prefer the 2nd one.

 

[Parlez]

What do you guys think? I prefer the 2nd one.

I like the 2nd one also but the first one is also good. It is just a shame that we can not have images in our signatures here *Cough* Munro.

 

[Penfold]

Not bad, but one mistake peolple always make is that their sigs are way too tall, and not long enough. If they are too tall, they take up too much valuable screen space when viewing a forum thread.

For instance, it wouldn't take many (ie 3) posts with your sigs attached to fill up the screen (depending on screen res obviously), when in reality there should be plenty of posts per screen.

I don't want to be too critcal, because they do look quite good, but they just need to be a bit more practical.

Personally, I end up adblocking most people's signatures on the day of defeat forums, and am extremely glad that image sigs aren't allowed here.

This is one of my sigs:

 

[sinkoman]

Meh, I don't like either.

The images that you chose to render, don't really interact well with the rest of the signature.

Not to mention, they both look VERY cliche.