spookymooky
Newbie
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2003
- Messages
- 2,013
- Reaction score
- 0
Well, the other thread was getting a bit annoying to read with all the spoiler/avoidance of giving info away, so I thought it'd be best to start a new thread.
Anyways, my impressions:
Goods:
Story tied up nicely. I was kinda hoping to see it end with the blockade runner running away from the star destroyer, but this was probably better.
Obi Wan was done nicely. I was really moved by "You were the chosen one!" at the end.
I really liked how anakin fell. He lost because of his arrogance, thinking he was stronger then Obi Wan despite the odds against him, and his 3 remaining human limbs were cut off. Anakin looked really bestial as he was burning too.
Anakin's temptation was done well in my opinion, Sidious's part was played well, and I liked how he tried to turn palpatine in, but was too desperate to save padme.
A really nice touch in my opinion was to clear up the dark side of the force: they made it so that it didnt run off pure evil, but rather passion, with anger just happening to be a strong emotion, but love was in there as well.
One of the few bits of dialogue i liked was the bit about Love leading to Greed.
Order 66 was just amazing, especially with all the planets they showed.
Bads:
Some incredibly cheesy dialogue, biggest failing in the whole new series.
Palpatines instant transition to sidious. Especially with the voice.
Grevious was so much cooler in the cartoon, and they didnt explain why he was wheezing.
The memory wipe thing at the end seemed thrown in.
I wish the republics military's transition to the empire's was done more subtly.
Never really explained who ordered the clone army.
Never explained whether or not the force could raise the dead.
Didnt do much with the whole force ghost thing.
So, what about you guys?
Anyways, my impressions:
Goods:
Story tied up nicely. I was kinda hoping to see it end with the blockade runner running away from the star destroyer, but this was probably better.
Obi Wan was done nicely. I was really moved by "You were the chosen one!" at the end.
I really liked how anakin fell. He lost because of his arrogance, thinking he was stronger then Obi Wan despite the odds against him, and his 3 remaining human limbs were cut off. Anakin looked really bestial as he was burning too.
Anakin's temptation was done well in my opinion, Sidious's part was played well, and I liked how he tried to turn palpatine in, but was too desperate to save padme.
A really nice touch in my opinion was to clear up the dark side of the force: they made it so that it didnt run off pure evil, but rather passion, with anger just happening to be a strong emotion, but love was in there as well.
One of the few bits of dialogue i liked was the bit about Love leading to Greed.
Order 66 was just amazing, especially with all the planets they showed.
Bads:
Some incredibly cheesy dialogue, biggest failing in the whole new series.
Palpatines instant transition to sidious. Especially with the voice.
Grevious was so much cooler in the cartoon, and they didnt explain why he was wheezing.
The memory wipe thing at the end seemed thrown in.
I wish the republics military's transition to the empire's was done more subtly.
Never really explained who ordered the clone army.
Never explained whether or not the force could raise the dead.
Didnt do much with the whole force ghost thing.
So, what about you guys?