Barney's "about that beer I owed ya" monologue is pure non-sense

[Goethe]

In HL: Blue Shift we play the Barney seen at the very beginning of HL knocking at a door. Now this Barney, which I suppose is the Barney we see in HL2, never told Gordon "catch me later, I will buy you a beer". True, it is possible that Barney told Gordon about the beer prior to the events of HL/ HL: Blue Shift, but since we don't know this the premise of the argument is non-sense.

 

[The Bait]

If you walk up to a Barney in the first HL they will say "Catch me later I'll buy ya a beer."

 

[bliink]

Barney's are coterminous

 

[jimmyjam]

both gordon and barney were brought into existence when half life started and thus had no way of ever meeting each other before!!! true facts!~@!

 

[guyofgames]

Most of the security guards you talk to in half-life are barneys... ex. the one sitting at the desk when you enter black mesa is barney.

 

[(Fragger)]

In HL, Barney is like Goofy in Disneyland: There's one every few feet.

 

[jimmyjam]

but not barney calhoun

 

[Death.Trap]

The Barney in HL2 is a manifestation of all the barneys from hl1 combined into one supreme Super Barney.

 

[Jay9475]

Death Trap speaks the truth, they hadn't realised players would become so attatched to the Barneys and other npc's and and for HL2 they wanted to bring them back but obvioulsy there'd been about 50 so they made them all into one kind of uber barney, from which all other barneys were wrought, whihc means that he not only went through blue shift but also owes you a beer from what he says in the original half life 'anomolous materials' chapter (I think its in that bit where he does the eye scanner for you, to access the test chamber),

-J

 

[Goethe]

The Barney in HL2 is a manifestation of all the barneys from hl1 combined into one supreme Super Barney.

lol - "the sum of all Barneys"

 

[Tupper]

Barney's are coterminous

Haha...

 

[duckmoose]

LMAO @ "the sum of all Barneys".

But really, I just take it as a tongue-in-cheek allusion to HL1, kind of like, "Let me do all the talking" or "Man of few words, aren't you?" and kind of assume that Barney met Gordon before the Resonance Cascade. It's too stupid to think all the Barneys are one guy as Barney Calhoun whom you played in Blue Shift is obviously the Barney in HL2, who never met Gordon during the game.

 

[Mountain Man]

* Zombie attacks *

"No! You killed Barney, you bastard!"

* round next corner *

"Barney! You're alive!"

 

[el Chi]

Do you not think that perhaps you're being hugely pedantic and shockingly dismal?

 

[duckmoose]

My post = sufficient explanation to swallow the game's plot.

 

[Tantalus]

i thought about the same thing. but wat the hell, valve made a mistake. big whoop.

 

[Kakashi]

In HL: Blue Shift we play the Barney seen at the very beginning of HL knocking at a door. Now this Barney, which I suppose is the Barney we see in HL2, never told Gordon "catch me later, I will buy you a beer". True, it is possible that Barney told Gordon about the beer prior to the events of HL/ HL: Blue Shift, but since we don't know this the premise of the argument is non-sense.

Why do we even care? Do you have to look for every little flaw? Who gives a rats ass?

 

[duckmoose2]

Gaaaah!!! Someone Get A Fire Extinguisher!!!

 

[Mr.Wotsit]

It makes perfect sense.

 

[kirovman]

Barney knows he didnt owe Gordon a beer...but Gordon wouldn't know that. Barney just owes the beer on his brother's behalf, but couldn't be bothered to explain the concept of his cloning experiment to Gordon, so..."Yeah, I'm THE Barney"

The others were wiped out in a horrible accident. Also if Dr Kleiner doesn't give the Barneys hormone injections every 24 hours, they become female, then die.

Just some pointless theories

 

[KagePrototype]

If this Barney is not the same Barney from Blue Shift, why is it that they're both called Barney Calhoun?

 

[Przemek]

Opposing Force and Blue Shift are Gearbox Software's creation, so we shouldn't treat everything from these addons as part of the HL2 story. Blue Shift showed us, the players, that Barney and the scientists escaped from Black Mesa, that's about it.

 

[Revenge]

I am Barnicus!

 

[Grumpy]

What is the problem, when you get off the train at the beginning and Barney opens the first door, you press the use key and he says the phrase! Play it, don'y spray it

 

[Kouler]

In HL: Blue Shift we play the Barney seen at the very beginning of HL knocking at a door. Now this Barney, which I suppose is the Barney we see in HL2, never told Gordon "catch me later, I will buy you a beer". True, it is possible that Barney told Gordon about the beer prior to the events of HL/ HL: Blue Shift, but since we don't know this the premise of the argument is non-sense.

You know, he couldve owed him a beer before the Black Mesa incident

 

[MigaS_tX]

First: Play Hlaf-Life. (the first one)
Second: right in the beggining, press the "use" key to the first barney you see.

He will say "Catch me later, i'll buy you a beer." .

 

[Sid Burn]

The Barney in HL2 is a manifestation of all the barneys from hl1 combined into one supreme Super Barney.

Yeah its true... he now thinks before attacking. and cant die so easily. :E

 

[EVIL]

I like Barney, he is my special friend! Qog!

 

[azz0r]

I cant even believe people question this, its a friggen game and its progresed to the point where they realised players got attached.

The Barneys in HL were never intended to be something people latched onto, but they did and thus they've fleshed out the idea of a Barney for HL2.

 

[kirovman]

If this Barney is not the same Barney from Blue Shift, why is it that they're both called Barney Calhoun?

Maybe they're all called Barney Calhoun.

And Gordon could have met Barney before the incident.
He only had to talk to him 4 times at the most before "catch me later i'll buy you a beer.

 

[CR33P]

maybe they resurrected barney from strands of his DNA found after he was massacred in HL1, and as for the many barney's in HL1, perhaps they were clones of the original Barney which were all made after barney promised to buy gordon a beer?

er...this is getting silly now isn't it

 

[Ravioli]

HELLO, everone, barney have known Freeman years before the Black Mesa thing, they have worked there for years, so barney could have sayd that before that day in Black Mesa. IDIOT!!

 

[subtlesnake]

It makes perfect sense within the plot because Gordon could have known Barney before. And before you go "well how come all the Barneys say that" perhaps Gordon had a special relationship with a security team.

And obviously it makes sense outside the plot as a kind of homage.

 

[kenyo]

Opposing Force and Blue Shift are Gearbox Software's creation, so we shouldn't treat everything from these addons as part of the HL2 story. Blue Shift showed us, the players, that Barney and the scientists escaped from Black Mesa, that's about it.

yeah, but they didnt right the story!
i heard that the righter of blue shift and opposing force was the same as half-life 1, valve just let gearbox make the game (off the story line they wrote), becuase valve was bezzy makin half-life 2!

 

[Goethe]

It makes perfect sense within the plot because Gordon could have known Barney before. And before you go "well how come all the Barneys say that" perhaps Gordon had a special relationship with a security team.

LOL -- even that's false, since some of the Barney's we meet in HL1 will say something like " You must be Freeman, right? " so not all of them knew him...

 

[Aether]

LMAO @ "the sum of all Barneys".

But really, I just take it as a tongue-in-cheek allusion to HL1, kind of like, "Let me do all the talking" or "Man of few words, aren't you?" and kind of assume that Barney met Gordon before the Resonance Cascade.

What about the reference Barney makes in the later part of the game, "Just like old times, eh Gordon?"

 

[The Monkey]

Unlike some of you, Valve has a sense of homour.

 

[subtlesnake]

LOL -- even that's false, since some of the Barney's we meet in HL1 will say something like " You must be Freeman, right? " so not all of them knew him...

So? Maybe he has a reputation around the bar. "Hey you must be Freeman, right - [the guy that hangs with the security team]"

 

[kirovman]

Maybe all the Barney's have a collective memory, and it is passed on to Barney in City 17.

Anyway, I noclipped off the tram in HL1 and bugged Barney until he said Catch me later i'll buy you a beer.
So at least I didn't get any storyline inconsistencies, my HL experience is untarnished

 

[duckmoose]

Okay, just assume Gordon met Barney before Half-Life 1. And instead of assuming the plot has some stupid "sum of all Barneys" thing, just take it as tongue-in-cheek as well, like the "just like old times." Or you could take that to be a reference to lots of things other than the idea that they fought side-by-side. Use some imagination, sheesh.