HL2.net membership's top 100 games - THE RESULTS! (slight 56k warning)

pomegranate

pomegranate

Newbie
Joined
Sep 30, 2004
Messages
1,795
Reaction score
3
Only a couple of comments from me...
Yes, there is a LOT of banding. This is because many games got the same total score. This wouldn't have happened if more people had participated, as more votes would have spread things out a bit. 67 people out of hundreds of active members is a bit disappointing (especially when the discussion of the IGN reader's poll stretched to 7 pages), but thanks to everyone who took a few minutes to compose their list! Ok, moaning over!

The top two games aren't going to surprise anyone, but that was never the point, it was to show that we as a collective have more discriminating tastes than revealed by the IGN user's poll, and that doesn't just mean giving the Half-Life saga big props. It certainly achieved that.

Tom

Oh yeah: There's actually 107 games here. That's because 9 games were banded together after the 98th, and it wouldn't be fair to drop any of them.
--------------------------------------------------------------




=99: Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick (PC, Troika Games, 2001)
=99: Final Fantasy III (NES, Square, 1990)
=99: Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic 2: The Sith Lords (Xbox/PC, Obsidian Entertainment, 2004)
=99: Loom (PC, Lucasfilm 1990)
=99: Medal Of Honor: Pacific Assault (PC, EA, 2004)
=99: Project Gotham Racing 3 (XBox 360, Bizarre Creations, 2005)
=99: Red Faction (PC/PlayStation 2, Volition, 2001)
=99: Secret Of Mana (SNES, Square, 1993)
=99: Sonic The Hedgehog (Megadrive, Sonic Team, 1991)
=97: Doom 3 (PC/Xbox, id Software, 2004)
=97: Final Fantasy IX (Playstation, Square, 2000)
=87: Command & Conquer: Generals (PC, EA LA, 2003)
=87: Cossacks: European Wars (PC, Strategy First, 2002)
=87: Star Wars Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast (PC/Xbox/Gamecube, LucasArts, 2002)
=87: Diablo (PC, Blizzard North, 1997)
=87: EverQuest II (PC, Sony Online Entertainment, 2004)
=87: Project Eden (PC, Core Design, 2001)
=87: Quake IV (PC, Raven Software, 2005)
=87: Team Fortress Classic (PC, Valve, 1999)
=87: Xenogears (Playstation, Square, 1998)
=87: The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker (Gamecube, Nintendo, 2002)
=85: Tom Clancey's Splinter Cell (Playstation 2/Xbox/PC/Gamecube, Ubisoft Montreal, 2002)
=85: The Dig (PC, LucasArts, 1995)
=83: Half Life: Opposing Force (PC, Gearbox Software, 1999)
=83: Tekken 3 (Arcade, Namco, 1997)
=81: Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 (PC, Westwood Studios, 2000)
=81: Rayman 2: The Great Escape (N64/PC/Dreamcast, Ubisoft, 1999)
=77: EverQuest (PC, Sony Online Entertainment, 1999)
=77: Final Fantasy Tactics (Playstation, Square, 1997)
=77: Full Throttle (PC, LucasArts, 1995)
=77: Medal Of Honor: Allied Assault (PC, 2015 Inc, 2002)
=72: Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri (PC, Firaxis Games, 1999)
=72: Burnout 3: Takedown (Playstation 2/Xbox, Criterion Games, 2004)
=72: Fallout (PC, Interplay, 1997)
=72: Unreal Tournament 2004 (PC, Epic Games/Digital Extremes, 2004)
=72: Worms (Team 17, Amiga, 1994)
=64: Burnout Revenge (Playstation 2/Xbox/Xbox 360, Criterion Games, 2005)
=64: Call Of Duty 2 (PC/Xbox 360, Infinity Ward, 2005)
=64: Command & Conquer (PC, Westwood Studios, 1995)
=64: Dungeon Keeper (PC, Bullfrog, 1997)
=64: Dungeon Siege 2 (PC, Gas Powered Games, 2005)
=64: Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (PlayStation 2/Xbox/PC, Rockstar North, 2004)
=64: Rome: Total War (PC, Creative Assembly, 2004)
=64: Star Wars: TIE Fighter (PC, Totally Games, 1994)
=62: Legacy Of Kain: Soul Reaver (Playstation, PC, Dreamcast, Crystal Dynamics, 1999)
=62: Super Smash Bros. Melee (GameCube, HAL Laboratory, Inc., 2001)
61: Curse Of Monkey Island (PC, LucasArts, 1997)
60: Day Of Defeat (PC, Valve, 2003)
59: Thief II: The Metal Age (PC, Looking Glass Studios, 2000)
=57: Freespace 2 (PC, Volition, Inc., 1999)
=57: Thief: Deadly Shadows (PC/Xbox, Ion Storm Inc., 2004)
=55: Age Of Empires III (PC, Ensemble Studios, 2004)
=55: Warcraft 3 (PC, Blizzard Entertainment, 2002)
=53: Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory (Various, Ubisoft Montreal, 2005)
=53:Street Fighter II: The World Warrior (Arcade, Capcom, 1991)
=51: Chrono Trigger (SNES, Square, 1995)
=51: Duke Nukem 3D (PC, 3D Realms, 1996)
=50: Beyond Good And Evil (GameCube/PC/Playstation 2/Xbox, Ubisoft Montpellier, 2003)
49: Quake III Arena (PC, id Software, 1999)
=47: Fallout 2 (PC, Black Isle Studios, 1998)
=47: Final Fantasy VI (SNES, Square, 1994)
=44: Battlefield 1942 (PC, Digital Illusions, 2002)
=44 Diablo II (PC, Blizzard North, 2000)
=44: F.E.A.R. (PC, Xbox 360, Monolith Productions, 2005)
43: Mafia: The City Of Lost Heaven (PC/Playstation 2/Xbox, 2002)
42: Planescape: Torment (PC, Black Isle Studios, 1999)
=40: Max Payne (PC/PlayStation 2/Xbox, Remedy Entertainment, 2001)
=40: The Legend Of Zelda: A Link To The Past (SNES, Nintendo, 1991)
=38: Call Of Duty (PC, Infinity Ward, 2003)
=38: Metroid Prime (GameCube, Retro Studios, 2002)
37: Command & Conquer: Tiberian Sun (PC, Westwood Studios, 1999)
36: Psychonauts (PC/Playstation 2/Xbox, Double Fine Productions, 2005)
=34: Super Mario World (SNES, Nintendo, 1990)
=34: World Of Warcraft (PC, Blizzard Entertainment, 2004)
33: Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty (PlayStation 2, Konami, 2001)
=31: Star Wars Jedi Knight: Dark Forces II (PC, LucasArts, 1997)
=31: Halo: Combat Evolved (Xbox, Bungie Studios, 2001)
=29: Final Fantasy VIII (PlayStation, Square, 1999)
=29: Unreal Tournament (PC, Epic Games, 2001)
=27: Aliens Versus Predator 2 (PC, Monolith Productions, 2003)
=27: The Legend Of Zelda: Majora's Mask (N64, Nintendo, 2000)
26: Company Of Heroes (PC, Relic Entertainment, 2006)
25: Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (PlayStation 2, Konami, 2004)
=23: Battlefield 2 (PC/Xbox 350, Digital Illusions, 2005)
=23: Homeworld (PC, Relic Entertainment, 1999)
22: Counter-Strike: Source (PC, Valve, 2004)
21: Grand Theft Auto III (PlayStation 2/PC/Xbox, DMA Design, 2001)


20: Operation Flashpoint: Cold War Crisis (PC, Bohemia Interative Studio, 2001)


19: Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind (PC/Xbox, Bethesda Game Studios, 2002)


=17: Final Fantasy VII (PlayStation 2, Square, 1997)


=17: Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic (Xbox/PC, Bioware, 2003)


16: Grim Fandango (PC, LucasArts, 1998)


15: The Secret Of Monkey Island (PC, LucasArts, 1990)


=13: Half-Life 2: Episode One (PC, Valve, 2006)


=13: Max Payne 2: The Fall Of Max Payne (PC/PlayStation 2/Xbox, Remedy Entertainment/Rockstar Vienna, 2003)


12: System Shock 2 (PC, Irrational Games/Looking Glass Studios, 1999)


11: Counter-Strike (PC, Valve, 1999)


10:Super Mario 64 (Nintendo 64, Nintendo, 1996)[/SIZE]


9: Metal Gear Solid (PlayStation, Konami, 1998)



8: Grand Theft Auto: Vice City (PlayStation 2, Rockstar North, 2002)


7: Command & Conquer: Red Alert (PC, Westwood Studios, 1996)


6: StarCraft (PC, Blizzard Entertainment, 1998)


5: GoldenEye 007 (Nintendo 64, Rare, 1997)


4: The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time (Nintendo 64, Nintendo, 1998)



3: Deus Ex (PC, Ion Storm, 2000)


2: Half-Life (PC, Valve, 1998)
​


1: Half-Life 2 (PC, Valve, 2004)






Let the flamewars begin!
 
That's a damned excellent list. Thanks for putting it together. You should email it to IGN and call them fruit bats.
 
I fail to see how cs:s is at a better position than the thief games. Oh, and MGS2 beats WoW? (the most successful mmo ever created?) As good as MGS2 was, i don't think it should beat WoW.
 
ewwww why is pacific assult on there. that was one of the worst medal of honors ever made.
 
Just because a game is successful doesn't mean it's great. *cough* Sims *cough*

Bleh at HL2 being #1 but that was a given on this site.

EDIT: KOTOR being that high? No f*cking way! Just because it was one of the few RPGS to actually make it to pc doesn't mean it's great. I hated that game.
 
MoHPA, i think, was pretty good. The weapons felt really nice, especially the rifles, and they tried their best to create that band of brothers type of relationship with the player/NPCs. Although it's an EA game, it was actually pretty good.
 
The thing you have to bear in mind here, is that not everyone who voted has experience of gaming going back to classics from the 80s and 90s.

If everyone here had played every game on the list, the order would be enormously different! :)
 
Thats a pretty damn good list.

Deus Ex should be 1st but besides that ;)
 
We're going to get the shit flamed outta us when a Halo site sees this.
 
HL2 should definitely not be #1 maybe somewhere between #20-#10. Half-Life should be number 1!!
 
I hate you all, Thief: the Dark Project and The orignal DOOM didn't make the list.

.....and Halo did
Ya'll sicken me

And wheres "Sam & Max"? Or Bloodlines? Warcraft II? (which was better than the 3rd, even though it was splendid)
 
Uriel...you didn't nominate ANY games, so how can you expect your favourites to be on there? If you had voted, and voted for Doom, it would've been in there. As it is, it's just outside the list at 108.
 
Saw the results of the poll before I saw the poll where the voting actually took place.
Although, more interested in the opinions of others and the specific game they chose out of a series.
Like DOOM3, Warcraft III & Thief.
....you guys really like the 2nd Thief more than the original?

Although Sam and Max should have been mentioned by others, atleast Monkey Island was up there.
 
MGS2 is wayyyy too high on this list.

Other than that though, big thumbs up!
 
Congratulations to HL2.net for making a list slightly less wrong than the IGN list :p

Post where the games you voted for ended up?

Final Placing / How you voted

1 / 1 - Half-Life 2
2 / 6 - Half-Life
3 / 5 - Deus Ex
12 / 2 - System Shock 2
23 / 3 - Homeworld
29 / 8 - Unreal Tournament [1999 - PC]
47 / 7 - Final Fantasy VI
77 / 4 - Final Fantasy Tactics
 
Zelda OOT-4
Counter Strike-11
Half Life 2-1
Super Smash Bros. Melee-62
Metroid Prime-39
Pokemon Blue-N/A(I f*ckin give up on this forum)
Halo-31
Mario Kart DS-N/A
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City-8
Katamari Damacy-N/A
 
No wonder you only got 67 votes, since this is the 1st I've heard about it.

The list sucks. HL2 shouldn't be 1st, and Max Payne 1 should be above 2. No Broken Sword games? No Starfox/Starwing.

You all need banned, killed, exhumed, then banned again.
 
StardogChampion said:
You all need banned, killed, exhumed, then banned again.
Click to expand...


Only if you voted for Halo

Still am shocked more people didnt go GaGa over Bloodlines, it was such a GOOD game. Few bugs but cmon, BF2142 has more
 
Remember that we only chose 10 games each. There were loads of games I would liked to have mentioned (SS2, Planescape, BG2, FF6, Mario Kart, Bomberman, Syndicate, Populous ..... and on and on), but they didn't quite make my final list.

For all we know Starfox or Broken Sword (or any other game that you feel is absent) would have been everyone's no.11 - and would therefore have appeared higher than many of the other games present.

Personally, i'm most impressed that the thread remained on topic and didn't become a flame war :)

Nice to see some N64 game make the top 10 by the way btw, and not suprising to see HL2 grab the top spot (this being a HL2 forum ;))
 
StardogChampion said:
No wonder you only got 67 votes, since this is the 1st I've heard about it.

The list sucks. HL2 shouldn't be 1st, and Max Payne 1 should be above 2. No Broken Sword games? No Starfox/Starwing.

You all need banned, killed, exhumed, then banned again.
Click to expand...

FORUM LISTS R SERIOUS BUSINESS!
 
Damnit, that was over fast, didn't get a chance to vote :p

Good stuff (from browsing the top 20)... HL is so best game though. HL2 wins best sequel :)
 
I wish I would have had a chance to vote, but this is a really cool thing you've done. And the list is actually not half bad.
 
HL1...shouldn't really be 2nd. HL2 deserves top spot, but Deus Ex should really be second. Goldneye in the top 10? I'm going to puke.
Otherwise...not a bad list, though I can't understand why Quake 4 is in the top 100.
 
Well, I guess I could have left it open longer, but I don't think that would have made any difference as, despite a bump by myself, by the sixth day the voting thread had sunk onto the second page of the General Gaming forum. Nothing else I could have done myself, if it had been stickied in the forum or made a news item that would've helped. Don't blame me if you don't notice a thread that runs for more than a week, though.


Uriel said:
Saw the results of the poll before I saw the poll where the voting actually took place.
Click to expand...

Ah, fair enough

Uriel said:
Although Sam and Max should have been mentioned by others, atleast Monkey Island was up there.
Click to expand...

Well, it is already saturated with LucasArts games, no?
 
Now THAT is a damn good list.

Dungeon Keeper and Cossacks both on it. :D They deserve it.
 
Great list! Mario, Goldeneye and Zelda in the top 10, nice.
 
If we could make another list, stickied this time, left open for a longer amount of time...?
 
Uriel said:
I'm kinda dissapointed

......Bitches
*waits for infraction
Click to expand...

Bloodlines was good, but it wasn't THAT good.

I would've put it in the top 30 atleast.

There was plenty wrong with it(gun combat being a total pain in the ass, every melee weapon handles the same, crashing randomly, physics acting wonky, etc.)
 
Jintor said:
If we could make another list, stickied this time, left open for a longer amount of time...?
Click to expand...

Erm, I think it'd be better to leave it till this time next year. I don't think people who have already posted would be too happy about doing it all over again. And tbh compiling it all was more work than I'd anticipated so :rolling: I'm not keen to repeat the task straight away. Something like this takes trial and error to get it right. I'll prepare a bit more next time...
 
pomegranate said:
Erm, I think it'd be better to leave it till this time next year. I don't think people who have already posted would be too happy about doing it all over again. And tbh compiling it all was more work than I'd anticipated so :rolling: I'm not keen to repeat the task straight away. Something like this takes trial and error to get it right. I'll prepare a bit more next time...
Click to expand...

Ooh, let multiple people work on the compiling bit next time as well!

*pick me, pick me!*

Maybe you should go around asking companies/magazines how they do their lists. I mean, they've got experience too. ^ ^
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

B
The other cancelled ports of Half-Life
Replies
3
Views
7K
Tollbooth Willie
Tollbooth Willie
B
Who's left or joined Valve in recent history
Replies
4
Views
32K
MFL
MFL
B
Hostile Takeover, the lost Half-Life expansion pack
Replies
6
Views
16K
Ennui
Ennui
Stormy
Game Critic Awards 09
Replies
4
Views
596
Musk
Musk
Asuka
Valve Reveals Lifetime Retail Sales + Garrys mod.
Replies
18
Views
2K
Operational
Operational
Back
Top