Quake series vs. Doom series

[Prince of China]

I don't see why this hasn't been posted before, it's been an age old poll. Quake or Doom?
Vote on the poll. It's simple. I like Quake.
Why? Well, **** you.

Games for Quake includes: Quake and the mission packs (Scourge of Armagon, Dissolution of Eternity), Quake II and it's mission packs (The Reckoning and Ground Zero), Quake III: Arena and Team Arena.
The unofficial add-ons don't count.
And for Doom, it would be: Doom/Ultimate Doom, Doom II, Final Doom, Doom III.

 

[ShadowFox]

Your reasoning is amazing.

I prefer Doom.

Quake 1 & 2 were good, but 3 was boring.

 

[Mechagodzilla]

Commander Keen was Commander Kickass!

 

[Bait]

Why? Well, **** you.

Your eloquence has forced me to my knees and made me cry like a little girl. Well done. You are only the third person to do such a thing.

Anyways, Doom I and II pwn nearly any game ever created. Evar.

 

[MultiVaC]

Commander Keen was Commander Kickass!

exactly

 

[KagePrototype]

Commander Keen by far.

 

[Mr. Redundant]

quake 1 beats all other ID games (sans rtcw)
simply because it was so easy to mod for, I was doing it the week I got it.. and back then I knew nothing about modeling skinning or anything.. but I could slap together a tommy gun in qmdl, with some rudementary skin and edit the quake-c and compile.. easy as pie.

 

[PvtRyan]

Never liked Quake really.

Quake 1 bored me (never played the MP of it) Quake 2 I only played on the N64, which was good fun, Quake 3 was horrible imo.

Doom is definitely better in my book.

 

[Cole]

*HL2 steps in*
*Owns them all*
ok back on topic.
I actually have quake 1, it's not bad i can see how it was a improvement over Doom 2(last doom i played i never got to Doom Final). guessing all the dooms used the same engine though.

Quake 3 has some decent mods..(Like NS:CO and Military forces(Military forces is a contineum from the air quakes) or truecombat)

I played Quake 2 on the pc and on the N64, i liked both the same really..

If i had do say anything.....It would be!!!!
QUAKE 1
If it wasn't for that ol quake 1 engine then HL might of been insaley crappy or not even made!

 

[outpost]

Commander Keen was Commander Kickass!

I have all of them!

 

[Letters]

Quake III Arena multiplayer demo was sweet... so I pick Quake!

 

[Asuka]

Wolfenstein

Was great cant wait for part 2.

Doom is close behind.

 

[ButtHoleMcGee]

Commander Keen in Goodbye Galaxy.

 

[A True Canadian]

I have all of them!

Were there 7 games or more? I've played all 7 (4 and 6 being my favorites, since they were free when I got my first PC ). Unless there's an 8th one I haven't heard of.

 

[Tr0n]

This is probally the hardest poll I ever took...Man...Quake or Doom.Can we choose both...?

 

[ailevation]

:dozey: I dunno, I really didn't enjoy either, but since Doom III has it's latest game out, I go for Doom III.

 

[MultiVaC]

Were there 7 games or more? I've played all 7 (4 and 6 being my favorites, since they were free when I got my first PC ). Unless there's an 8th one I haven't heard of.

There were 6, plus that lost episode 'Keen Dreams' one (which I didn't like as much). Those were great games, I'd like to see a sidescrolling game come out with modern technology as the official 7th episode. Every game is 3D nowadays, a 2D ultra high-res Commander Keen would be really fun. I miss the sidescrolling games, you can't replace them.

 

[Dr. Freeman]

both series were/are so good and both have given me fond memories.. argh
its tough to pick

 

[NeLi]

Doom II, of course. If you do not choose the DooM series you're an INFIDEL.

The pinky demon will own your soul.

 

[<RJMC>]

I loved quake 1 for the satanic things