Which looks better?

[SubKamran]

This'll be interesting.

http://www.subkamran.com/lib/files/hl2-d3-comparison.jpg

Personally, HL2 looks better.

 

[BillyJoBob]

I vote hl2.

 

[P43.2/1Gig/X800P]

i vote hl2

 

[urseus]

How about you post a fairer screenshot.

How bout i post a doom3 screenshot that actually shows part of the game on a higher res than 640, say ultra high graphics on 1600.

Compare that to the majority of the hl2 screenshots, most of which dont even seem to have aa or af on.

 

[The Mullinator]

I refuse to vote because I know what kind of flame war picking sides could start.

 

[Dr0ndeh]

no comment until ive played.

 

[DrEvil]

hl2 by far. I don't like games that are dark. Hl2 has the full spectrum of colours, I love it.

 

[Rafa 5.0]

None, I pick GTA:SA, j/k

 

[Lobster]

Thats the worst comparison ive seen yet, different situations, one taken from a video showing off features of the engine that may not even be seen in the final game, and the other a really dodgy ingame image, ill vote hl2 just cause i dun like doom3s style at all, but man at least make it a fair fight !

 

[SubKamran]

Thats the worst comparison ive seen yet, different situations, one taken from a video showing off features of the engine that may not even be seen in the final game, and the other a really dodgy ingame image, ill vote hl2 just cause i dun like doom3s style at all, but man at least make it a fair fight !

Then compare against my own screen: http://www.subkamran.com/stuff/lib/img/games/doom3_1.jpg

Those features WILL be in the final game (albeit HDR added later). You could also compare the G-man (high-res version) to a close up on a DOOM3 character. Valve said that all the *main* characters will be lookin' that good.

So there

 

[DvS]

This kind of thread is called a firestarter, you should have enough intelligence to figure out why.

1. Really, really bad comparison.

2. Why those two? do those two screenshots sum up the games?

3. In before close

 

[Chris D]

Closed upon request of the original author.