Break down of events, please discuss.

Joined
Jul 17, 2003
Messages
2,258
Reaction score
0
All right, I'm going to try and analyse what has happened post Sept 30 up to the other day when Valve 'announced' a possible release date.

Last I remember being happy was the months before September, Valve (Doug) was telling magazines and websites that Half-Life 2 was right on track. Everything was going smooth as could be. September 30th is just days away.... and Valve hasn't announced that Half-Life 2 has gone gold. September 25th~, people start saying that Half-Life 2 is delayed. And then, on the big 30, nothing happens. The Half-Life 2 community paused and the 30th just rolled right by. What happened?

All right, here's the first 'point of conflict'. I believe most people are against Valve on this one... why didn't they say anything? A few weeks prior they were announcing everything was good to go, what happened? Here is my take.. many of you say Valve lied by saying everything was on track just a few weeks prior to the release, when it wasn't. To be honest, I can't prove to the community what Valve did, and did not know at this time. But, you can't just point the finger because it was delayed and blame them for not telling us in advance. (Or maybe you can..)

I've had quite a few people say that just before September 30th (literaly days), they were reading interviews in magazines from Valve (Newell and the gang) and how everything was going perfect. Just to point out, this was in magazines, which take a few weeks to process. That interview could have taken place in early-mid August.

All right, what's next on the line? 'A while' after Sept 30, Valve was still doing the occasional interview. Nothing vastly interesting or gripping, but at least saying that they were still alive at the Valve offices. This was also around the fabled "Holiday Release" date given. People were in an uproar at Valve. "Holiday Release?!?! What does that mean?!?" I have to admit, the date was a little 'general'. And we can never forget those funny Flash Movies about the delay. :E

And now, perhaps the spark that blew everything up.... the leak. I remember people posting pictures of the buggy openly on our very own half-life2.net forums. The mods letting it slide because OFCOURSE it coudn't be real. People posting it and getting replies like "Ohh, good job on the buggy model" and then one guy was telling how it was obviously fake because they were "Raven Shield Textures". I thought they were to (I mapped for a RVS mod and I thought I recognized the textures, after a quick double check, they didn't match) It had to be fake right?

When 'most' of us found out the delay was real. First thought: "Half-Life 2 is destroyed". I suspect most people here downloaded the beta. I didn't, but then again I can't prove that. Here's where stuff gets vey ugly, and the community starts to split between the "I hate Valve" and the "I love Valve" which, in my opinion, is worse then Half-life 2's delay itself. The first thing brought up about people with the beta is "This is all they had done, they had been lying to us for months" From what I understand, there is a date on the beta somewhere which is prior to E3, but not by much. Some say the hacker changed the date, and that it would have been very easy to do so. I don't think anyone can take anything solid from this if at all.

Here's one of the bigger issues: Were the events scripted or not? Now, it was pretty much confirmed from the community that most of it was scripted. Such as the scene where the combine soldier kicks in the door to chase Gordon. Also, from what I understand, people said that the AI's just kind of 'stand there' most of the time and, if this build is pre E3 build, it is possible the AI just was not implamented fully. Perhaps the barricade (sp?) scene truely wasn't scripted. I don't think you can take solid information from that either, though, people seem to have done just that.

Ofcourse, the Holidays are gone now, no Half-Life 2, and we've had the largest media blackout ever after the acknowledgment of Half-Life 2. People speculate March, April,.... July and EVEN September 30th of 2004. This is bad and great news at the same time. Same thing (Minus the Leak and split in the community :farmer: ) happened to the original Half-Life. It was delayed for ages. It may have lost some of its graphical appeal at the time, but it took it from a normal shooter.... to THE shooter.

Many people are pissed at Valve for being straight up silent. I don't blame them (I don't blame Valve). Look at what happened every time they ever tried to convey something to the community about Half-life 2. And like I've said, when a game get's delayed, it needs more work, but when Valve delays a game, suddenly they 'lied'. Maybe Half-Life 2 needed more work. Sure, it's possible that Valve could have told the community sooner, but we don't know that. And either way, it's delayed. Moving on to today....

What's this? An ACTUAL 'area of time' for Half-Life 2's release?! Straight from Valve?! This summer, Half-Life 2 'should' be here. Now, don't just think "Valve lied before, it's not going to be here". Statistically, most games get delayed at least once. A lot of you need to be more realistic about this stuff. (Remember Diablo 2? Hehe....) Valve has probably serveyed what has happened, what they've done, and want to take a while to go over and give Half-Life 2 that polish that Half-Life had. If this is the case, I hope we all enjoy Half-Life 2.



All right. Thank you for reading. Please post your own thoughts on the subject. I know some of you don't like Valve right now, that's fine. People can analyse and make their own conclusions. Post your thoughts people. :)

The first thing I'm going to think when I load up Half-Life 2 for the first time (Hopefully) is "It was worth it."

Have a nice day. :thumbs:
 
Stop creating new threads for topics that are already being discussed retard.
 
..wow, no need to be mean, iamaelephant.

Anyhow, I'm not sure what you want us to discuss anyway, Top Secret
 
iamaelephant said:
Stop creating new threads for topics that are already being discussed retard.

calm down dude :)

oh and Top Secret, you forgot why HL2 was delayed: over 86% of it's source code was assimiliated into the Matrix, with Revolutions as the Product! Aren't we glad HL2 wasn't released on Sept. 30?!
 
iamaelephant said:
Stop creating new threads for topics that are already being discussed retard.
Don't speak to people like that.
 
I was just trying to analyze why people are mad at Valve and if people had any valid point about it. I think 'most' people jumped on the bandwagon on the subject and never stepped back and just looked at everything.

iamaelephant:

Please edit your post. It adds nothing. I'm not here to insult you.
 
Nah, its bullshit. Because there was a leak, I bet there doing a total rework in the game engine, spruseing it up perhaps, maybe not. I dont know, Im not a Valve drone. Im not gonna call Valve lier's, but what I can say about them is they are undependable.
 
oh and Top Secret, you forgot why HL2 was delayed: over 86% of it's source code was assimiliated into the Matrix, with Revolutions as the Product! Aren't we glad HL2 wasn't released on Sept. 30?!

Hahaha, yeah. That's the W. brothers used the source code to make Matrix's dramatic battle scenes. :)

sorry.......

I think he was refering to iamaelephant.
 
I'm not going to edit my post, but you created another thread that pretty much discusses exactly what you want to discuss here. As for not wanting to insult anyone here
Everyone pissed at Valve, needs to grow the **** up. Their game was delayed. It happens. Get over it

Whatever man.
 
I'm not going to edit my post, but you created another thread that pretty much discusses exactly what you want to discuss here. As for not wanting to insult anyone here

Then obviously you didn't read both posts fully. My first thread, just basically said that I think a lot of the is ignorant (not all :) ) community. I took a side. This post is from a more neutral view and just a lay of events to (hopefully) help people see what happened.

Whatever man.

I could sit here and start a flame war with you. But I am not going to.
 
"Quote:
Originally Posted by iamaelephant
Stop creating new threads for topics that are already being discussed retard.

Don't speak to people like that."

Yes I was...
 
well put top secret. we cant single out valve as being undependable. of course there is the fact that they miss release dates, but that is standard for the gaming industry as a whole. they have bad pr, and havnt been giving the community news, which we hate the lack of it, but i do understand. everything that comes out of their mouth is just torn apart. if i were in a situation where anything i said to my fans pissed them off, be it good news or bad, i would also keep quiet. valve have been quiet for this reason, and i think after they have taken the time to finish the game they intended to make, they will release it and be able to sit there and say, "here you go, i think youll find our product to be worth the wait, as well as all of the bitching."
 
. valve have been quiet for this reason, and i think after they have taken the time to finish the game they intended to make, they will release it and be able to sit there and say, "here you go, i think youll find our product to be worth the wait, as well as all of the bitching."

That's my new sig.
 
yea, i just think of valve as the type of company that's never on track.

but hey, they make great games so im not complaining :)
 
iamaelephant said:
Stop creating new threads for topics that are already being discussed retard.

Cant we all just get along? ;(
 
I think you pretty much got the events right but I disagree with the point that the date may have changed in between interview and magazine printing. There are quite a few emails from people at valve and they all say even close to the sept 30 release date that sept 30 was the day.
I honestly don't know why they would say sept 30 and not change their story even when it became obvious hl2 wasn't going to ship then. Many people (not me) upgraded (foolishly) because they wanted to have a system capable of running hl2 well, and I think that's caused a lot of the ire directed at them.
 
Many people (not me) upgraded (foolishly) because they wanted to have a system capable of running hl2

I think you made a lot of good points, but don't call the people who upgraded are fools. :) I'm running Far Cry on Very High and enjoying it. Same with Max Payne 2 and Gothic 2. Hell, I went from 25 frames on Raven Shield on medium to 80 + on highest possible with 4x AA and 16x AF. It was worth it for me.
 
Top Secret said:
I think you made a lot of good points, but don't call the people who upgraded are fools. :) I'm running Far Cry on Very High and enjoying it. Same with Max Payne 2 and Gothic 2. Hell, I went from 25 frames on Raven Shield on medium to 80 + on highest possible with 4x AA and 16x AF. It was worth it for me.

Thats sweet, what are your specs? :p
 
The more and more I think about it, I believe Valve isn't a bad game development company, they are just a poorly managed company. For Valve to be developing a game (with a full staff) for five plus years signals that they have problems organizing and planning the development of their games. Look at ID software, they have fewer people on staff (I believe) and yet they (probably will) release a brand new engine and game in less time than it takes Valve. I know creating computer games is difficult, but it seems like Valve can't keep its focus on anything. They switch from design to design and game to game without making a firm commitement to anything. I am accusing Valve of incompetence at the business level, not the game development level.
 
Thats sweet, what are your specs?

3.0C
1 gig Corsair XMS pro 2 ram
9800XT
p4p800 deluxe
Audigy 2 zs

How did I do it? I mowed the lawn for 5 years, that's how I did it.

Made it myself. :)
 
top secret, im honored to be your sig.
people, once this game hits shelves, i believe all of this valve bashing will wash away as we all get to enjoy this game. were all just a little tense b/c we have so much expectation and its lasted for so long.
 
kaf11 said:
top secret, im honored to be your sig.
people, once this game hits shelves, i believe all of this valve bashing will wash away as we all get to enjoy this game. were all just a little tense b/c we have so much expectation and its lasted for so long.

My exact thought
 
Yeah, that was a really good post kaf11. I hope this whole situation kind of falls behind us.
 
blahblahblah said:
The more and more I think about it, I believe Valve isn't a bad game development company, they are just a poorly managed company. For Valve to be developing a game (with a full staff) for five plus years signals that they have problems organizing and planning the development of their games. Look at ID software, they have fewer people on staff (I believe) and yet they (probably will) release a brand new engine and game in less time than it takes Valve.

I'd think that has a lot to do with the fact that id is pretty much concentrating on doom 3 alone, while Valve has to divide their effort on HL2, CS, DOD, TF2, Steam and possibly CS2. I don't know how many Valve guys are working on each, but I think they have small teams for each of those sort of "secondary" games and a bigger group of people concentrating on HL2.
 
iamaelephant said:
Stop creating new threads for topics that are already being discussed retard.

Shut up, he put more effort into his reply than you. And he actually used his brains and stuff...

OT: I can agree with it, I suppose Valve could have told us sooner, but by what? A week or two sooner? Would that have made any difference to the final outcome that the game was delayed? Whether they told us or not, we wouldn't have had the game anyway if they told us sooner, and we're not even sure they could have. People draw their conclusions too quickly, especially with such little information, after the info comes out, why it was delayed, THEN be pissed at Valve.

They're not delaying it to see you get pissed off, I'm sure they're having a laugh of all the worked up kiddo's flaming them, but it wasn't the reason they delayed it. From what I've read the "game simply isn't done" and that happens. Learn to live with it. The game will only get better, Half-Life was probably crap before they delayed it a whole year and rebuild the entire game. Diablo 2 was like you said delayed a long long time, and turned out to be one of the greatest games ever. Blizzard may not produce a lot of games, but when they do, they do it right. Same goes for Valve. I'd rather see a revolutionary HL2 in 2007 than a crappy one in 2003. I'll keep myself busy with games like Doom 3, Far Cry and S.T.A.L.K.E.R.

It's not like they're developing the cure for AIDS, we can wait. And if you're truly a HL2 fan you'll accept Valves choice to delay it and trust them that they make a great game. If you're not a real HL2 fan, then wtf are you doing here? Get lost!
 
finally were getting some logical responses to the delay drama rather than more of that "valve lied to us, we hate valve, etc..."
 
iamaelephant said:
Stop creating new threads for topics that are already being discussed retard.

That was not nice.

:borg:
 
Alot of people are misreading ( again) :

VALVE SAID: We're targeting summer for COMPLETION of halflife 2. We don't know when it's released..but around that time, but it could be september.
So they have been VERY CLEAR, and don't whine when it isn't here at summer.
 
It seems strange that in May (or March, my memory fails me) it will have been 1 whole year since VALVe announced HL-2.

If it *is* delayed until September I'd take it as a good sign, HL-1 was delayed a whole year and it turned out to be probably the greatest PC game ever made.
 
iamaelephant said:
Stop creating new threads for topics that are already being discussed retard.


haha stop being a baby :LOL:
 
blahblahblah said:
The more and more I think about it, I believe Valve isn't a bad game development company, they are just a poorly managed company. For Valve to be developing a game (with a full staff) for five plus years signals that they have problems organizing and planning the development of their games. Look at ID software, they have fewer people on staff (I believe) and yet they (probably will) release a brand new engine and game in less time than it takes Valve. I know creating computer games is difficult, but it seems like Valve can't keep its focus on anything. They switch from design to design and game to game without making a firm commitement to anything. I am accusing Valve of incompetence at the business level, not the game development level.

I think your mistaken, ID might release an engine, maybe even a 'buy to experience' tech demo, but an actual game? With a plot? Please we've more chance of world peace before that happens. We are talking about John 'plot is secondary' Carmack here. Enough of this foolish talk of ID games. :rolleyes:
 
I agree, DooM 3 is a movie that kills the hell out of your PC when you try to run it.
 
mortiz said:
I agree, DooM 3 is a movie that kills the hell out of your PC when you try to run it.
Actually I'm pretty confident that Carmack will make a very optimized engine and will run on any medium to high machines. Where I agree is that Valve is developing some amazing content to run on their engine. Where Valve is discussing 'What kind of bond does Alyx have to Eli and how will this affect her attitudes, actions and motives during the combine raid on Eli's hide-out in the rising action portion of the story? How does she behave towards Gordon? How does this event change the characters?' (something likethat). Id is going along the route of 'So... marine is looking for super-weapon on mars... let's go make some dark, shadow-filled levels!'
(or something like that).
 
ID software having a storyline. Can you even use those word in a sentence like that? IS it even possible? If thats true then i can easily conclude god does exist.
 
First, I think we shouldnt be bashing this guy. He made a long, thoughful post, and he deserves to not be flamed just for that fact. Just because its been made before doesnt mean he needs to burn in hell. I mean, what else is there to do around here anyway?

but when Valve delays a game, suddenly they 'lied'. Maybe Half-Life 2 needed more work. Sure, it's possible that Valve could have told the community sooner, but we don't know that. And either way, it's delayed.

Wonderfully said. People get way too angry when a big game is delayed. Its almost always better in the long run, because we will have a quality game instead of buggy trash thats not good until patches eventually fix it 6 months later. Might as well delay it.
 
HL-1 was delayed a whole year and it turned out to be probably the greatest PC game ever made.

Hey man, as far as I'm concerned, you can safely take that 'probably' out of there. :)
 
mortiz said:
I agree, DooM 3 is a movie that kills the hell out of your PC when you try to run it.

I'd say it's a movie that forces you to upgrade your entire machine and then probably kills the hell out of your PC still ;)
 
Back
Top