Edge review HL2 :)

Warbie - I don't mean to intrude, but is it possible to change the topic title to indicate the score from Edge? ;)

This is BIG news considering how notoriously hard the magazine is to impress.
 
concept, can you link us to the forum?
 
the thing is right

lets just wait until thursday people
 
KagePrototype said:
It's an obvious copy and paste at gamesradar, even the "!" after the pro:ev score is there as well.
Click to expand...

I've only been online a short while and have just been checking the news for five minutes guys, give me a break. :p

It doesn't help that Rllmuk are down right now either.
 
probably us lot invading their forums, they probably aren't used to that much traffic :p :)
 
whenever i click on the link previously posted by some people all i see is this

what am i supposed to see?
 

Attachments

  • edge.JPG
    edge.JPG
    97.4 KB · Views: 314
Sai said:
whenever i click on the link previously posted by some people all i see is this

what am i supposed to see?
Click to expand...

Like Mortiz said, if you're referring to Rllmuk, it'll have been all the traffic interested in the Edge scores all over the web to there which has knocked the place down (temporarily).
 
for those who cant be bothered to click links the quote is...

dude from gamesradar forums said:
I guess some people want some sort of text from HL2 review im not sure that is allowed?

Ill post i tiny bit and then if it not allowed ill re-phrase it
Quote:
HL 2 is a 1st person shooter. But in actio, storyteling, technical achievemnet, atmosphere and intensity it has far out done its peers. Valve just hit a top note no other PC gamer could reach


Well it seems juding is done on a slifding scale, not what is a good game but what is a good game compared to what else is around, am i reading that wrong?
Click to expand...
 
Wow. This is pretty impressive if it's true.

*giggles and waits for Nov 16th*
 
It's funny that some Halo fans over there have the same kind of venom for HL than some people here have for Halo. It's like the bizarro world!
 
how can people say halo 2 is going to be better than hl2 as soon as i heard about hl2 i totally forgot about halo 2
 
P43.2/1Gig/X800P said:
how can people say halo 2 is going to be better than hl2 as soon as i heard about hl2 i totally forgot about halo 2
Click to expand...
Because people have different opinions.

I know, its appaulling.
 
10/10? Thats just not right.

See, Other games got 10. So you're playing a game rated 10, and its good, but where do you go from there? Where?

HL2 gives that extra push, it is one better.

HL2 goes all the way to 11.
 
f|uke said:
10/10? Thats just not right.

See, Other games got 10. So you're playing a game rated 10, and its good, but where do you go from there? Where?

HL2 gives that extra push, it is one better.

HL2 goes all the way to 11.
Click to expand...

*sigh* and we manage to go full circle yet again.

10/10 doesn't mean the game is perfect - it means it's an example of the best that genre has to offer at the time (genre defining, revolutionary - what ever you want to call it)
 
f|uke said:
10/10? Thats just not right.

See, Other games got 10. So you're playing a game rated 10, and its good, but where do you go from there? Where?

HL2 gives that extra push, it is one better.

HL2 goes all the way to 11.
Click to expand...

unless you're on a rating system from Spinal Tap
 
So, i'm reading this, and i'm interested in Edge - thing is, i'm in the USA. Is it that good that i should consider importing it? Can anyone give me more info?

Thanks
 
I'm amazed that people are still going OMG 10/10, 98% etc etc.

Hell, we hoped this game would be special. The reviews have confirmed that and this new one doesn't tell me anthing other than what I already knew......

HL2 will be amazing!

.....and a 9/10 would not have dampened my enthusiasm (any more than a 11/10 would have lifted it!)
 
f|uke said:
10/10? Thats just not right.

See, Other games got 10. So you're playing a game rated 10, and its good, but where do you go from there? Where?

HL2 gives that extra push, it is one better.

HL2 goes all the way to 11.
Click to expand...

Bahahaha, that was great- I've alwase thought HL2 should go to 11.
Spinal Tap rules.
 
cool news. Also, what you said about the 10/10 rankings and it being a great game of its time, i didnt know that. Is it like that for all reviewing magazines ect? If it is then ive been misunderstanding them for years lol! (thinks maybe he should read the "what do the reviews mean" section in PCGamer...)
 
There was a magazine that gave HL1 11/10 wasn't there?


Wonder if they'll do it again for 2
 
Dr.breen said:
There was a magazine that gave HL1 11/10 wasn't there?


Wonder if they'll do it again for 2
Click to expand...

Wasn't that PC Accelerator...which was shut down? :(
 
YAH!!!......i want hl2 now!!!...... as more and more reviews are giving hl2 awesome reviews the hype and the anticipation just keep increasing......i think tomorrow i'm going to start having a nervous twitch..... :sniper:
 
Spiffae said:
So, i'm reading this, and i'm interested in Edge - thing is, i'm in the USA. Is it that good that i should consider importing it? Can anyone give me more info?

Thanks
Click to expand...

It's a multiformat magazine - and definately recommend it if you're into gaming, and the industry, as a whole.

Edge is know for being fair, but very critical. The reviews/previews are informative and unbiased. It gets exclusive developer interviews, a behind the scene look at the making of classic games, articles on how gaming has evolved over the years etc Edge basically covers all the basic stuff every other mag does (but with considerable more style and substance) and then adds a whole wealth of information.

The magazine itself is also very high quality - excellent screenshots, page layout, high production value (makes other gaming mags look like cheap comics) It is that good :)

An intelligent look at gaming as a hoby :)


ManHacks said:
cool news. Also, what you said about the 10/10 rankings and it being a great game of its time, i didnt know that. Is it like that for all reviewing magazines ect? If it is then ive been misunderstanding them for years lol! (thinks maybe he should read the "what do the reviews mean" section in PCGamer...)
Click to expand...

I assume it's this way with all publications - otherwise it wouldn't make any sense :)
 
Warbie said:
It's a multiformat magazine - and definately recommend it if you're into gaming, and the industry, as a whole.

Edge is know for being fair, but very critical. The reviews/previews are informative and unbiased. It gets exclusive developer interviews, a behind the scene look at the making of classic games, articles on how gaming has evolved over the years etc Edge basically covers all the basic stuff every other mag does (but with considerable more style and substance) and then adds a whole wealth of information.

The magazine itself is also very high quality - excellent screenshots, page layout, high production value (makes other gaming mags look like cheap comics) It is that good :)

An intelligent look at gaming as a hoby :)




I assume it's this way with all publications - otherwise it wouldn't make any sense :)
Click to expand...

sounds like you're trying to sell the magazine to me...

oh well it worked!!!
 
They should pay me a cut ;)

Hope you like it :)

(it'll be worth getting the next issue just for the HL2 review - assuming that it did really get 10/10)
 
Warbie said:
They should pay me a cut ;)

Hope you like it :)

(it'll be worth getting the next issue just for the HL2 review - assuming that it did really get 10/10)
Click to expand...

Someone from NTSC-uk (a new source not relating to the initial score posts on Rllmuk just in case people start again), has listed the contents of what's in the re-designed issue and re-confirmed Edge has given Half-Life 2 10/10. Here's the link - Check the last few posts.

http://ntsc-uk.domino.org/showthread.php?p=357635#post357635

On a side-note, it's great to see Fumito Ueda interviewed once more. Whatever you say about Edge, when they give a game 10/10, you know it genuinely has to be something special to receive such a score. :)
 
If the 10 score is true (and it looks like it may well be) this is the best sign yet that HL2 is going to be somethink special.I trust this mag more than any other though I agree that 10 for Halo was a bit much.However, the other 10's it has given out have been pretty much spot on.
HL2 will now officially rock. :bounce:
 
tomo13 said:
If the 10 score is true (and it looks like it may well be) this is the best sign yet that HL2 is going to be somethink special.I trust this mag more than any other though I agree that 10 for Halo was a bit much.However, the other 10's it has given out have been pretty much spot on.
HL2 will now officially rock. :bounce:
Click to expand...

Or maybe halo was a great game. I expect nothing less of Halo 2
 
Either way, HL2 sounds very special :) \o/
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

bbson john
Hi everyone. I am new to this forum!
Replies
11
Views
6K
Tollbooth Willie
Tollbooth Willie
MFL
Fascinating look at the ongoing psychological evolution of flat hieirarchies.
Replies
2
Views
2K
Tollbooth Willie
Tollbooth Willie
Omnomnick
Erik Wolpaw Still At Valve: Retracting Our Round-Up
Replies
5
Views
10K
MFL
MFL
B
The other cancelled ports of Half-Life
Replies
3
Views
7K
Tollbooth Willie
Tollbooth Willie
Spamming Tanks
The Pre-Order Thread
Replies
14
Views
3K
Spamming Tanks
Spamming Tanks
Back
Top