The Man in the Picture...

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ghost
  • Start date Start date
G

Ghost

Guest
This would not exactly be a spoiler per se, since this photograph is availible at the very start of the game. The photograph is seen on the wall in Dr. Kleiner's Lab. In it is depicted what we can assume to be the scientists who were working on the Teleportation Experiment.

What is bothering me, however, is one man in particular. Of the nine people in the picture, five can be identified with a great deal of certainty. Three of the other four may be excused as being generic, but it is the last who stands next to Dr. Freeman that I most concerned about. I'm hoping the upload file feature works well ofr this site. I have numbered them to make this easier.

1 - Unkown #1. There is a possibility this might be Dr. Rosenberg who is featured in Blue Shift, however, there is the problem that, as of yet, Blue Shift has not been fully endorsed by Valve as official Half-Life Cannon. This is due largely in part that it never has Barney interact with Gordon, while HL2 suggests they did.

2 - Eli Vance

3 - Unkown #2. Female. Not sure if this was Alyx's mother, but I don't think so. If I remeber the photo in Eli's lab she was much prettier and skinnier. If anything they added a generic female scientist for some sort of balance.

4 - The "Einstein" model, one of the four generic scientist models used in the original Half-Life.

5 - An assumption I admit, but I would say Dr. Breen. Who else would Kleiner scratch out?

6 - Unkown #3. Male.

7 - Dr. Kleiner. He can be connected to the generic scientist model of "Walter" in HL1.

8 - The Man. The Legend. The Pimp. Gordon Freeman.

9 - The Mystery Man. Have you noticed anything yet? Maybe it's just me. Here are two theories I have:

A) The last generic scientist model. There were 4 in HL1, 3 are used. One is Eli, one is Kleiner, the last is "Ein." The fourth scientist in HL1 was the youngest looking one, though older than Freeman.

B) The GMan himself. I personally doubt it, but I want to know what others think. When I look at that picture, I'm reminded of him : http://www.vossey.com/half-life2/perso/gman.gif

The problem of course is that the 4th generic scientist in HL1 and the GMan do look alike in HL1. Perhaps they reused the texture for the Gman or vice versa. Still, the man in the picture does look like the Gman to me for some reason.

But then, I have my doubts. Could it be the GMan watching Freeman? He is standing next to him? But that doesn't seem to be his style. But then, perhaps, this was the GMan before he becomes "the GMan." Perhaps this is how he has his "abilities;" he was a scientist who worked on the project himself. When you exist outside of time and space (if you interpret his role that way), would it matter WHEN you gained that ability? But then, what about his "eployers"?

I'd like to write more on this but I'm tired. I'm interested in seeing what others have to say about it as well.

So, #9 the Gman or the Generic Sci #4? And if it is the GMan, what would that mean for the plot of HL?
 

Attachments

  • ThePicture.jpg
    ThePicture.jpg
    86.5 KB · Views: 6,015
Nice synopsis, and I fully agree with you. The female is not at all Eli's wife...
 
I believe it's g-man... but I've always had a feeling that g-man isn't human and is a part of something much much much larger than we know about. I think he's outside of the benefactors and the combine and all of that - just overlooking everything.
 
To that I definately agree, and I believe him to be the nemesis of the Combine and it's purpose. I'll write on that idea in a seperate post, my interpretation anyway. Still, every man has his origin, if indeed he is a man. Will we see this in the future? I suppose only time <-REFERENCE) will tell. Heheh. Still, more opinions are welcomed.
 
It's not gman...it's another one of the generic scientists at Black mesa.
 
I agree with Zento, in Half-Life there was a generic scientist with black hair, no unlike the G-Man. But, I believe it's just a scientist.
 
i beilve the g-man we see is just a host body for who ever is using him.
 
that looks a LOT like G-man. If you remember, somewhere in the dialogue in the begining of hl1, you can faintly hear G-man talking to kliener or another scientist about listening to the 'benefactors' or something along those lines...

I wouldn't be suprised if it's g-man weasling his way into a possition where he can have some say in the way things happen.
 
I'm pretty sure it's generic #4. They have the generic Einstein model so why not include the other one?

It's actually impossible to say because generic #4 and the G-man looked exactly alike.
 
heres a comparison i made:
 

Attachments

  • c1a00004.jpg
    c1a00004.jpg
    22 KB · Views: 643
Wraith said:
heres a comparison i made:
odd, i must have played through the entire game like 10 times but i have never ever been striken by the resemblance.. as i still don't now. IMHO they don't look THAT MUCH alike, the texture bears some resemblance, but that's it.

it's scientist #4 on the picture
 
also here is a look inside the gmans breifcase using noclip, for the first one i had to piece together 3 different pics because i couldnt get the gman to stop moving around, as you can see he carries a gun with him at all times. (and an ID card?)
 

Attachments

  • Image3.jpg
    Image3.jpg
    50.5 KB · Views: 444
did anyone try to noclip the briefcase in HL2 ? did valve put stuff there too ?
 
i just did it, spawned a gman with npc_create npc_gman, turned on notarget and noclip, nothing in there, just a solid block of confusion
 
nah, nothing inside the case.
(btw i went at the beginning of water hazard where you see him overlooking the river, noclipped then avoided the trigger_ by going around it)
 
Here's the original textures from inside G-man's briefcase in HL1...

(sorry for bump btw)
 
I think its pretty obvious that the guy on the far side of the picture is not the Gman and is infact the 4th scientist head (Slick) from the original though admitidly they are alike.

The mysterious Gman Briefcase was written out of HL1, I think it was going to be one of the main parts of the story, they also took out his silenced pistol as I remember.

I think we need to worry more about the face in the picture that has been tippexed out and had a red cross drawn over it.
 
Its so obviously this guy. End of discussion.
 
Tycell said:
I think its pretty obvious that the guy on the far side of the picture is not the Gman and is infact the 4th scientist head (Slick) from the original though admitidly they are alike.

The mysterious Gman Briefcase was written out of HL1, I think it was going to be one of the main parts of the story, they also took out his silenced pistol as I remember.

I think we need to worry more about the face in the picture that has been tippexed out and had a red cross drawn over it.

The red X guy is obviously Breen.
 
Back
Top