RakuraiTenjin
Tank
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2003
- Messages
- 8,099
- Reaction score
- -2
Didn't they tell us in an interview somewhere that it is, in fact, Barney Calhoun from Blue Shift?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: this_feature_currently_requires_accessing_site_using_safari
PatPwnt said:brian... is that hor the beginning goes in blue shift? barney banging on the door?
impaqt said:This is acutally pretty simple and logical, I'll lay it out and sum it up for those of you that don't understand.
Some of you say that they shouldn't use Adrian in HL2 because some people didn't play OP4. Obviously that argument is pointless since all three games share the same storyline, only from different POVs.
impaqt said:It wont confuse any players, it will only seem like a new character to them..
And if Barney was to say that then a player that hasn't played BS would assume that Barney did actually do that
Its alright to assume because you know the characters but you've really gotta think about the original story line first and why the extra plots just won't be needed to someone who hasn't played these other mods.
impaqt said:Uhm, it's got a background story. The player just doesn't know it. If you ask me they have to make the game follow the plotlines they laid out with the first generation of games, which in other words mean they can't deviate too much without losing storyline credibility.
Look at it this way ; If you start reading a series of books, but for some reason skip the first two books then there's obviously going to be holes in the story. Valve can't really take this to account when making a storybased game..
The thing is that those expansionpacks aren't mods with additional storylines, they are just the original storyline seen from another POV, which reveals more of the story.
bigun said:so why do you think theyve included barney in HL2? and i doubt barney and gordons conversations are going to go into the detail you described a la 'floating platforms''.
Basically what I'm saying is that you can scrap the other 2 views and still be left with more than the basic story from start to finish. And that is the truth is it not? Halflife never needed another 2 expansions to explain anything whatsoever. Adrian and Barneys stories don't add anything to what happened with Gordon. They coincided but didn't effect the main plot. what your arguing is for a OP4-2 not HL2.
Orange said:I'd like to see Adrian make a cameo. One of the neat things in Blue shift or Op For was seeing the same thing happen that Gordan did from a different perspective.
If you didn't remember, it was just someone's experience. If you knew the reference, it was a neat little nod.
BTW, Shepard is the only character of the 3 that we don't know what he looks like.
It'd be kinda shocking (and neat) if he was listed as a casualty after fighting against the Striders, or just briefly mentioned in a non-pivotal way.
There it doesn't matter if you've play Op For, and doesn't hurt people's perception if they hadn't. For those who HAD, it would be a cool reference.
impaqt said:I'm not arguing for OP4-2, I'm just trying to explain how those two expansions told the parts of the story which couldn't be told in one game alone.
Champ said:Did they add nothing to the story? Are you ****ing kidding me? They let you see the incident from a whole other perspective, furthermore were we able to explore Black Mesa just a wee bit more. I find it extremely ignorant to just brush all ideas aside that's about Adrians part in HL2 (if he has any).
Including Adrian for any players who haven't played Op4 is a matter of storytelling, as I also said in my earlier post. G-man could introduce him as another agent sent to C17 for all we know. Oh well, your posts just leaves me the impression that you're uncompromisable (or whatever it's called, heh). You simply don't want him in there do ya?
I totally agree on that. That's why we'll see Eli and kleiner back, but no Adrian...Bicka said:Thats not fair to say that though Brain Damage. Barney was a generic guard in HL1 yes and everyone loved him. The generic soldiers on the other hand weren't all called Adrian and nobody really cared what happened to them.
It doesn't make sense if you try using Barney Calhoun from Blueshift because he never met or talked to Gordan in the game.
The Barney Calhoun in HL2 is not the guy from Blueshift only. He's every Barney mixed in one.
I totally agree on that. That's why we'll see Eli and kleiner back, but no Adrian...
anyways, he'd seem out of place.
G-Man, Gordon this is Adrian Shepherd, he was sent in to kill you, but ended up becoming a bit of a nuisance so I had him put in observation
we11er said:OK this is a pretty big thread and I can't read it all - so apologies if this has already been said.
BUT remember that Half-life 2, in terms of the story, isn't a game, it's a "world". And in this "world" Adrian Shepard is an important character. The fact is the G-man wouldn't just dispose of him (or maybe he did, who knows) so he could indeed have a part to play in the future of the half-life story. Probably not HL2 but quite possibly an expansion pack.
Rafael said:The problem with Corporal Sephard is that the character has bound a much bigger event in the story telling. Gess what? Yup, the Black Mesa nuking. In Half-Life it doesn't happens or you aren't aknowledged of it, but at the end of Opposing Force it's clearly stated. If the (suceful) nuking of Black Mesa wasn't planned by Mark Laidlaw but the Gearbox crew, then it basically destroy a lot of possible side-histories. How did Barney, Dr. Kleiner and Dr. Vance (who where basically near you when the resonance cascade happened, but without any HEV suit to protect him) among others, survived the nuke?
Anyway that's only one of the several problems.