Gray Fox
Newbie
- Joined
- Aug 22, 2004
- Messages
- 6,568
- Reaction score
- 1
I'm talking at the time. At the time it was logical to think a God created everything because...well anyone got a better explanation? No one really did at the time. Today however it simply is silly and illogical. I'm talking thousands of years ago.
Badgerman said:In fact, a lot of the 'illogical rules' in the Bible were in fact very logical, but only really applicable back in the time in which it was written. The laws against homosexuality exisit simply because there weren't that many people. Therefore the emphasis on sex for procreation.
Religion tends to develop alside a structured society, as I've mentioned before - seemingly to justify the existance of the status quo - for example the emphasis on poverty as a viture, and in a sense justify the existance of the govermental system.
I do not agree with that, in the video posted before featuring Richard Dawkins he says:
Science is a dicipline of investigation and constructive doubt, questioning with logic, evidence and reason to draw conclusions.
Faith by contrast, demands a positive suspension of critical faculties.
Science preceeds by setting up hypothesese, ideas or models and then attempts to disprove them. So a scientist is constantly asking questions, beeing sceptical.
Religion is about turning untested belief in to unshakable truth trough the power of institutions and the passage of time.
Now no matter what time religion is still illogical, furthermore it does not take modern science to disprove a religion, Aristoteles, Plato and their followers managed to disprove it by simple logic and reasoning, no empherical evidence needed to be put to the table to expose the governing paradoxes. There were however no means of disproving their main believe in how the planet was created and us humans, but reason alone could cast doubt weather or not they(religius people) were lying about that too.
And while I am sure that bastardized version of religion have served their purpose troughout history and helped civilazation progress in light of what Mecha has posted one cannot but come to the conclusion that if the bible is very very illogical even for it's own time and had it been follow as the bible says it should have been followed it would have had negatieve effects on humans now, but also then. And since the bible explicitly says that only what it says is the christian religion, by logical reasoning you cannot conclude that christian religion has ever helped civilazation along since it were the bastardized versions that served that purpose and they cannot be considerd true christian religion.
I used Christian religion and the bible as an example but this offcourse applies to most of the major religions today.